Most helpful customer reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
The real Toby Dammit at last!, Dec 20 2010
With the new Blu-ray release from Arrow, we finally get the genuine English soundtrack of Fellini's masterpiece, with a fully restored transfer of the whole film. Having ordered it from Amazon.uk on the understanding that it was a region-free release, i can now confirm that it plays perfectly on North American machines (or at least on mine) and looks and sounds great. Arrow has provided lots of soundtrack and subtitle options so you can also view it with the French soundtrack -- which in fact is the preferred option for the middle of the three films, Louis Malle's "William Wilson". But it's "Toby Dammit" that really makes this film a classic, and for that, you really need Terence Stamp's own voice. All the voices were of course dubbed in after shooting, as was the practice in Italian films at the time, but Stamp synched with himself beautifully, and the rest of the cast (who mostly speak in Italian) also sound much better than in the French dubbed version. When i saw this trilogy in the theatre in 1967, i was blown away by Toby Dammit, though the other two films struck me as mediocre. 40-odd years later i feel pretty much the same, although the other two are a bit more interesting now, if only for historical reasons. I've seen some great Fellini films since then (La Strada, 8 1/2) but for me, this is his best. This Blu-ray is worth buying for that alone. However, instead of extras on the disc, it comes with a 60-page booklet which includes a couple of essays by Tim Lucas and Peter Bondanella, which are very informative about the story behind this French-Italian production, Histoires Extraordinaires (the European title). The book also includes the three original Edgar Allan Poe stories on which the three segments are based. I might mention that as of late December 2010, the Amazon.uk price (shipping and all) is considerably less, after conversion, than the price listed here on Amazon.ca -- where it's not in stock anyway. I hope the price comes down here too so more Canadians will come to know this unique film.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
It Could Have Been Great, May 7 2002
This review is from: Spirits of the Dead (Widescreen) (DVD)
Janus Films participated in the restoration of this film and you would think that that alone would ensure high standards of quality. And for the most part it did. But unmentioned in all the reviews of this DVD is the fact that the best film of the three, Toby Dammit,does not have its English soundtrack included. Terence Stamp is English and he spoke his part in English.(and what an amazing bit of verbal it was) It just ain't the same thing in dubbed French by another actor. An earlier release of this film delivered the English soundtrack as an option but did not allow you to turn off the English subtitles! (Some of the people that put these things together are really lacking in simple, common sense.) Also the image quality on the previous release is faded and not real sharp. Image quality on this current DVD is excellent. Rich color and very sharp. So the horror of it all is you are left with a very well done restoration with a rather important detail inexplicably left out. The English soundtrack exists and isn't this the whole point of DVD's? I took a chance buying this DVD hoping for an improved version that fixed some of the problems on the earlier release. The frustrating thing is that it is so close to being there, but a French speaking Terence Stamp is just absurd. Janus Films was also involed in the Criterion Collection new version of Amarcord and they did it perfectly. Everything is there. Wish they used as much care on this one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Fellini Makes Films Like My Dreams--Exquisite Bliss, Jun 24 2004
These three short films, loosely adapted from stories by Poe, are all packed with stunning landscape and exquisite set design. However, only Fellini's film manages to create a story worth retelling in its own right. The first film is Roger Vadim's "Metzengerstein". The best thing I can say about it is that the gorgeous horse was the most effective actor in it. He knew his lines, and nodded when appropriate. Jane Fonda plays Contessa Frederica, an occasionally sadistic libertine who develops a passionate romantic attachment to the aformentioned horse. She is wondefully cruel and gorgeous, making the most out of some truly inspired little outfits. The segment is filmed by Claude Renoir, who captures some stunning images breathtaking beauty. Again, the scenes with the horse galloping and cavorting with Frederica are rather intoxicating. The story itself, however, is sacrificed on the alters of atmosphere and aesthetics. The end result is a very empty film. Louis Malle's "William Wilson" basically has two really excellent scenes that make this worth watching. The first is a simple send-up of an autopsy. Wilson is demonstrating for his fellow Medical School classmates, the proper introductory procedure for performing an autopsy. Except, where his instructor had used the corpse of an old man--Wilson had bound a lovely, living lass and is preparing to dissect her. The other great scene involves Brigitte Bardot. Throughout this film, Bardot is unflatteringly coiffed in a black wig that is pulled back in a rather schoomarmish fashion. Her eyes are seductive, but she doesn't demand the kind of camera worship she has so often received in other films. However, the hair comes down and Bardot is soon being subjected to Wilson's birch rod. Her face, hair, and the slashes on her back are aesthetically quite sublime. Alain Delon is fair in the title role, but he lacks any real charisma. Between him and his doppelganger, I think they both possessed nearly as much charisma as the horse in Vadim's film. Overall, this film also sacrifices its story to the look of the film. The end is rather intense and powerful in its own right, but it lacks significance because the story itself isn't carried forth with any conviction or authority. Terence Stamp is Toby Dammitt in the final film, directed by Federico Fellini. He really does an outstanding job looking washed out, confused, sick, drunk, and completely at the end of his tether. The film itself is phenomenal. It is by far the most absurdist and melancholy of the three films. In this adaptation of Poe's story, "Never Bet the Devil Your Head", Toby is jaundiced with everything possibly gained by fame in this life. He seems to represent the insidious truth of fame. He is also haunted by a sweet little girl in white, bouncing a big white ball. The scenes relating to her are the best, in my opinion. She is a sylph with terrible symbolic power. What does the ball mean? Why is she so demonstrably joyful? She can be read as pure and active--a regenerative force that is the impetus for new life. She certainly is spooky and charged with energy. She is clearly something that Toby's psyche cannot accept. Ultimately, the viewer is made privy to a series of associations in Toby's mind that help us understand his relationship with the little girl. But we are not made aware of her exact role in his downward spiral. It is impossible to fully convey the magic that Fellini captures with this film. From start to finish, there is a typically "Felliniesque" hyper-surrealism that transports the viewer into another dimension. This is the only film of the three that manages the rather daunting feats of transcendence and cinematic art. Nino Rota's score is haunting and hypnotic throughout. An absolute masterpiece overall.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most recent customer reviews
|