5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Lesser Known Biblical Commentary, Jan 23 2011
By Rod Zinkel "Parish" - Published on Amazon.com
The discourses that make up this book are not often referred to in other works and do not expound on the existentialist philosophy Kierkegaard is known for. These are more like traditional biblical commentary. George Pattison explains that this book is meant for lay readers, not scholars, and so some editing is required, modernizing some language, changing the frequently used masculine pronouns he and him, and cutting some length. I could not say for brevity because, while the discourses are not overlong, so many are based on the same biblical verses, so that the effect is, at times, tedious. Pattison admits the author may have intended to teach patience by this.
The discourses of Part I and the first few of Part II and III are the strong essays, in part because the others seem repetitive. Each part has a theme: Part I - the gift, which emphasizes all we have is from God; Part II - the bird and the lily, emphasizing all we can learn from the figures Jesus tells us to consider; Part III - love and forgiveness. There are important lessons here; some are rather unique. An example is from the first discourse, in which K writes that wanting God to give the perfect gift as we define it would limit God, as though he knew nothing more than we do. There are thought-provoking statements, such as "Woe to those who are so proud as not to be able to forget what makes them different, but woe, too, to those who are so lowly as not to forget what makes them different."
The format of the e-book is fine, though unnumbered footnotes present a problem.
1 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Some Dense Reading, May 23 2011
By Momazing "Student of Christianity" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Spiritual Writings: A New Translation and Selection (Paperback)
This book is very enlightening, but I suggest some Bible knowledge before reading it. It is very dense. You wouldn't take it to a coffee house to read.