1.0 out of 5 stars
Star is hardly the word., July 6 2004
The settings are perfectly all right. The situations that the main character has landed herself in are plot devices that many an author had undoubtedly used - but this is forgiven when they are crafted into the storyline creatively and we forget they are not, well, cliches. The thickness of the book suggests it should be a good read once you snuggle in bed. All right, I admit, I am grasping at straws for Star's positive points. You see, in this book, there is a flaw that you might disregard as insignificant, but to me, it is the primary reason why I could not enjoy this book as I had with countless books written by other authors.
The main heroine is despicable. You might argue, why does this deserve a one-star rating? Because whenever I take my time to read the book, I want to sympathize with the characters and *especially* the main character, who I will be following throughout the whole book. Sadly, in Star's case, it is only the contrary that happens.
Theoretically, one who read the book would claim this description is absolutely far-fetched. One would claim she is a tragic heroine with a dark and troubled past, even more so when she is raped by a relation. One would claim she ran into the big world with only herself to survive. If she had any bad points in her character, then the book made sure not to stress on them. The book paints her to be a matryr, like some reviewers have pointed out. This is evident from the moment you turned the first page. We are meant to sympathize and feel with her character, and I'm sure a whole lot did, but for me, it does nothing more than to make me smile and think about Steel's other heroines and whether or not they have made cameos in disguise. Of course, this is only the first few chapters so I am more than willing to give the book a chance to develop her character more.
The book progressed on, and there was nothing remote about her that changed. It takes a likable character to get absorbed into a story like that, and she is no likable character. Her portrayal as the beautiful woman who captured the hearts of everything that moves is exasperating, tenfolds more when the book kept stressing it continuously up to the point when I actually took out my temper on my cat, the poor soul. In this new world she is in, help is delivered readily. I can tell you, from my experience, that there is a fine line between fantasy and reality. But of course, this is a book - anything could happen as the author wishes it to be. It is hard to enjoy the rest of the book when it is revolved around this heroine. I would think staring blankly at a moss-painted wall would offer more enticement than listening to other side characters moan about her smooth beauty. Side characters that have potential to be more but, unfortunately, never explored deeper, I might add. What else is there to say about them, when all they did was play the roles of the heroine's helplers and marvel at her weak frame?
John Grisham's creations are a marvel. Sidney Sheldon's heroines jump into the most unlikely situations, but they are likable. Nora Roberts might be wordy but her leads are tolerable. Nicholas Sparks fall into those categories. Danielle Steel's other books might've been bestsellers, from what I've seen, but reading Star or well, Princess Diaries, I'm sure it's quite evident how I feel about the book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1.0 out of 5 stars
Redundant, Redundant, Redundant...., Jan 30 2004
This review is from: Star (Paperback)
I think this book had a great plot. And that's about it as far as greatness goes. I don't prefer her writing style. While reading through, it's hard to tell what character's feelings are being conveyed as she changes character thought in mid paragraph. I would rather hear one chapter from one character's point of view. I think that she tries too hard to get her point across by saying the same thing but in different ways. You can see it page after page. Crystal needed to get out of town. Crystal needed money first. Crystal needed to graduate, but she needed to get out of town. You get the point just by having it written once! Is there a word quota she was trying to achieve, hence the same sentences being thrown around?
I think it was just plain over written.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No