6 of 8 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Fans got "exactly" what they asked for!, Aug 17 2006
This review is from: Star Wars Episode VI: Return of the Jedi ( Widescreen Limited Edition) (DVD)
Finnaly, here is a chance for fans to own the "original trilogy" (Ep. IV, V & VI) untouched/unaltered for the first time on DVD... But for a limited time only!
These will be released individually on 09/12 as 2 disc DVD's with the 2004 "Special Edition" on the first disc and the unaltered "original version" on the second disc.
Fans have been crying to get the "original version" of these movies on DVD's for quite some time, so what's the problem? Well apparently the "original versions" (unlike the 2004 SE) won't be remastered/cleaned up nor will they be released in "Anamorphic" state.
But people... This is what you asked for! Sure, they could have taken the time to remaster them and make them "Anamorphic" but then if they had, these would no longer be the "original versions" and would not be the way fans originaly viewed them! Some people are just never happy no matter what...
Personally, these will be better than my "full screen" VHS tapes (which I no longer have) so I will be buying them. However, I wish they had not included the 2004 SE for those of us who already bought them on DVD back in 2004. Still, DVD's are not indestructible and have been known to rot or break down from time to time... These can always serve as a "back up" copies.
Regards
-Seb
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
"The Original Trilogy,Once More", Sep 3 2007
This review is from: Star Wars Episode VI: Return of the Jedi ( Widescreen Limited Edition) (DVD)
INTRO:For the first time on DVD in 2006 the "original" films of the Star Wars trilogy were released,fans are finally getting the chance to see the original movies,"IV:A New Hope","V:The Empire Strikes Back" and "VI:Return Of The Jedi" as they were shown in theaters back in 1977,1980 and 1983 respectively.Altought those DVDs are said to be for a limited time only,its almost sure that there is going to be another version or release of those "as seen in theaters movies" in a special edition sometime soon.
ORGINAL,REALLY?:This is said to be the original movies,but still some of the mistakes like the blue rod wich held the Millenium Falcon model,that were present in the original version are not present here,making of them not so original,but i beleve that those are minor changes that don`t affect the movie in any way and doesn`t prevent it of being good.
THE MOVIE ITSELF:1983`s Episode VI:Return Of The Jedi is the third movie of the Star Wars series,once again featuring Luke and CO. in this second sequel to "A New Hope" and they ecounter once again with Darth Vader and discovering who he really is,not to forget the classic and memorable "Luke...I Am Your Father",Episode VI is a great enjoyable movie from beggening to end.While it might seem dated compared to the prequel trilogy in terms off sounds and effects it remains amazing.
TWO DISCS?:It is a very nice option to choose between two versions of the same movie,the original version and the special edition version.That way you can choose wich you want to watch and compare the two releases,but why didn`t they make a box set ainvailable as well as the separate movies,it would have contained the three movies togheter,seems like a no-brainer to me.
ONCE AGAIN:This marks the what?4rth or 5th time the original Star Wars trilogy has been released!Enough is enough!In 1992 it was released on VHS as "the orginal,one last time",then the 1996 "special dedition also on VHS.In 2004 it was once again released this time on DVD with a bonus disc and then the nest year,2005 they released the same set without the bonus disc and in 2006 this "original and special editions" two discs set of "A New Hope","The Empire Strikes Back" and "Return Of The Jedi".So my question i:how many more times must the original Star Wars trilogy be released?Bad news a boxed set of the 6 Star Wars movies in a "special edition" with changes will be released....
OVERRAL:Its great to have those original movies but there still some changes(minus one star),and its another re-re-re-re...-release(minus one star also).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No