1.0 out of 5 stars
Sick of Dreadfully Violent and Depressing Star Wars Books, July 5 2004
By A Customer
If you like the implacable enemy, bloody violence and lots of it, Jedi are weak saps that can barely escape the "dark side", this is the book for you. Not that Stover does not have talent, but I am sick of the excessive violent (NC-17 if on the screen) claptrap that Star Wars books have been marked by since "New Jedi Order". I know that "Clone Wars" is about the disintegration of the Republic and murder of the Jedi, but do all the books have to be written by authors from the DARK SIDE?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
The tale only gets interesting in the last pages, Jun 15 2004
I bought the novel because it dealt with one of my favorite characters. But it has quite disappointed myself... it reminded me so much of "Splinters of a minds eye" which centered on Luke's second encounter with Vader face to face but you had to read 300 pages of boring pages until you got to the interesting part.
In this book you learn of Mace's journey back to his home planet in his search of his missing Padawan: Depa. Depa had been on a mission to make the local Guerrilla join the Republic and fight the planetary forces which had joined the Separatists.
You will see how Mace finds out by himself how has his ability to control the force diminished and lost many of his capabilities.
But I was mentioning before that you the good thing was in the last pages. It's true. You have to endure boring chapters and chapters of Mace's adventures in the jungle until you find interesting stuff. This almost made me leave the book but somehow managed to keep on reading.
The story is not bad, but it could have shortened to a 200 page book, and you would have gotten the same...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
dark, gritty, and the best Star Wars that i have read, Jun 11 2004
This review is from: Star Wars: Shatterpoint (Hardcover)
After "Attack of the Clones", this is the first novel to be set during the Clone Wars. With the war between the Republic and the Separatists raging all over the galaxy, the Republic has sent out the Jedi to create insurgency on various planets to fight against the Separatists. The Republic is not used to full scale war and has only a scant clone army compared to the countless droid army of the Separatists. The Jedi, while powerful, are not soldiers and walk a fine line between the path of the Jedi and that of the Dark Side. The Jedi Council sent Council member Depa Billiba to Haruun Kal (the birthplanet of Mace Windu) to aid in the battle against the Separatists.
Something goes wrong. The Council receives a message that shows a massacre of civilians (women and children) that is purportedly orchestrated by Depa herself. This should be unthinkable for a Jedi. Against the judgment of Chancellor Palpatine, Mace Windu decides to return to his birthplanet and investigate. You see, Depa Billiba is more than just a Jedi; she was once Mace Windu's Padawan apprentice. Palpatine wonders if Mace would be able to strike down Depa if the situation calls for it.
Mace journeys alone through the jungles of Haruun Kal in search of Depa. The war that is taking place is one that has been going on for generations (it is, ultimately, a civil war), but with the Clone Wars having begun and the Separatists having interfered, there is a new level of brutality and genocide taking place. It is into this horror that Windu arrives.
"Shatterpoint" is unlike any Star Wars novel that I have read. It is much darker (which fits the jungle theme), and it is a violent novel. It is also a much better written novel than what one might assume with the Star Wars name attached to it. No matter what universe this story takes place in, "Shatterpoint" is a very good novel. It just happens to be Star Wars. I appreciated the switching of viewpoints between the typical third person storytelling to excerpts of "the private journals of Mace Windu". Between the two perspectives, Matthew Stover did an excellent job of storytelling, and both felt appropriate. While in the movies, Windu has a very limited role (even being a Senior member of the Jedi Council), but "Shatterpoint" gives Mace Windu a voice and a personality and we get an excellent idea of what sort of man Windu is and what drives him. We see his strengths and his flaws and he in one novel he is a stronger character than I had possibly imagined him to be. No longer is Mace the Jedi who is interesting only because he is played in the movies by Samuel Jackson. He is a character who was given a dark, gritty novel. "Shatterpoint" brings the Clone Wars into perspective and shows how it impacts individual planets, what it is going to bring to the Jedi and why, and the difficulty the Republic will have in possibly winning the war. We even see what it might take and all of this is told in a story about one little planet and a fallen Jedi. I can only hope that "Shatterpoint" will be indicative of the quality of the Star Wars novels (past and future), because this is a very good one.
-Joe Sherry
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No