6 of 9 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting, readable, but not all that insightful., Sep 23 1998
By Christopher Weaver "weaverc" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Stephen King (Paperback)
This is an interesting collection of essays on King's early novels--from "Carrie" (1974) through "The Talisman" (1984). It's got some interesting things to say about images and structures of the novels--I particularly enjoyed his comparison between Jack Sawyer in "The Talisman" and Huck Finn. The essays include comments from both from interviews with the author and quoted from other sources. But Winter is really more of a fan than a critic, and his praise tends to be a bit too gushing and somewhat less critical than I would hope. A readable book and interesting if you're into King and horror commentary. But I'm still waiting for a more insightful commentary on King's work.
4.0 out of 5 stars
An entertaining, if dated, review of King's early work, Jan 18 2011
By Lawrence Zieminski - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Stephen King (Paperback)
Part Biography and part review of King's literary and film works (up to the mid 80s at least), this book was very interesting. The author is an avowed King fan, so it is not a surprise that he praises everything King wrote up to that point (of course, all that stuff was awesome, so I can't fault the author for that).
I learned a few things from the book, including the fact that the Dark Tower series was expected to be released as a large collection of short stories (The Gunslinger is a collection of 5 related short stories, though now we just consider them all one book). There are several references to The Cannibals, including its original title "Under the Dome," which it eventually retook when it was published recently. I found the most interesting aspect of the book was finding out when King wrote everything (books weren't necessarily written in published order and some of the story collections were written over many many years).
I'd like to read an updated version of this book, bringing in all the work he's done over the 25 years since this book came out.