0 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting Questions, Sep 28 2009
This review is from: Stepping Through The Stargate: Science, Archaeology And The Military In Stargate Sg1 (Paperback)
I am really interseted in this, as I am a bit of a newcomer to the Stargate 'Verse. I came to it through Stargate Atlantis, and I prefer that show to SG-1. I do not anticpate that Stargate Universe will be better than its predecessors, however I am intrigued. Anyway, I really hope they do an essay collection about SG Atlantis.
I was interested that there wasn't really a specialized discussion of aliens and how that relates to cultural understanding of 'othering'.
I was interested to compare it to SGA, where Bates is evil, is in a coma, and then is ok. Ford is ok, then an addicted power maniac, then ok, then probably dead. Teyla has always been cool, and Ronon... well he's not the most diplomatic person ever, but he and Lizzie are my favourite SG characters of all time, followed by Vala. So don't insult them in any way, shape, or form. Except if you do it snarkily and with love, like McKay
Plus, they wear the uniform way less than SG-1. Maybe because they're physically closer to Earth, and Lizzie's okay with it, so it passes. And then it's embedded, and Woolsey has to grin and bear it. Because Teal'c and Vala haven't given up their cultural identity or anything... but Teyla's and Ronon's have more storyline. And what about the accents. Well, yes, lazy (as opposed to making up whole new accents)... plus if they have neutrally Canadian or American accents, then why not British or Indian accents, for instance?
Also, what about the whole 'Teyla fashion' and Vala 'sex kitten' thing? If they didn't work as people, and the storylines weren't great, I'd get pissed.
Plus, great contrast to Aeryn Sun on "Farscape".
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No