I love stories that span generations. It provides so much opportunity to evolve the characters and the plot. With 15 hours (ten 90 minute episodes roughly) to tell the story, I had high hopes of a truly epic and meaningful story. Taken was neither epic nor meaningful. Every episode, I kept waiting for something to move the plot forward, or change the characters in some significant way (these are the precepts of good story telling, that and a challenge to overcome). At the end of most episodes, I came away feeling disappointed. There was no plot. Everyone was a victim or a bad guy. No heros, no one to root for, no one you could feel good about. The challenge in this story was for the abductees to stay out of the clutches of the "evil government organization", and for everyone to try and figure out what the aliens were up to. Normally, you expect the hero to prevail. But, there was no hero, and nobody prevailed. In fact, everyone's situation just got worse. Several characters were victims of their own evil ways, and the rest were just victims. In this respect, Taken is a tragedy, and the only light at the end of 50 years of people doing bad things to each other is the little girl who finally explains what it's all about. A barely profound 10 minutes of revelation after 15 hours of poor setup for such a simple climax. It might have worked if they forced themselves to tell the story in 3-4 hours. At least then, you could get the same experience without having to wade through so much otherwise useless drama.
I suppose seeing the totally disparate reviews on Taken (here and elsewhere) just points out how many different perspectives there are for good story telling and good sci-fi. I guess I should accept that for many people, alien abduction stories, no matter how badly produced, are always a hit. For such people, Taken provides 15 hours of what you probably like most. A few people have likened Taken to a soap opera. Perhaps that's the appeal I'm missing as well. If you want 15 hours of an alien oriented "Days of Our Lives." Buy the DVD. If you want good story telling, with interesting characters that evolve, a plot that moves and something you'll likely watch again and again, don't buy Taken. In my opinion, this mini-series should have been called "Took." That's how I felt after seeing it on TV. Especially considering what the SciFi channel canceled in order to push this mini series on us.
If you must, catch it on the SciFi channel the next time it comes around. With so many other excellent choices on DVD, don't waste your money to buy Taken.