10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Sunflower Forest, July 8 2003
By Peter Friederici - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Sunflower Forest: Ecological Restoration and the New Communion with Nature (Hardcover)
Ecological restoration has often been viewed as either a fringe hobby -- a few aficionados re-creating a patch of prairie on weekends -- or as a distraction from the vital and politically charged work of preserving more or less undisturbed landscapes. But William R. Jordan III argues that it's vital to the preservation of the Earth's ecosystems, and to ourselves. Jordan, founder of the journal Ecological Restoration, writes that restoration is "a way of achieving an ecologically close relationship with the rest of nature," as well as "a context for confronting the most troubling aspects of our relationship with our fellow creatures." The Sunflower Forest is an important book about a practice that is, in coming years, bound to become one of the most important ways we deal with our surroundings. Thanks to Jordan's wide-ranging intellect and compelling writing, it's also a great pleasure to read.
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Way more than eco-philosophy, Aug 25 2006
By Paul Grant "historian-in-training, author, sp... - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Sunflower Forest: Ecological Restoration and the New Communion with Nature (Hardcover)
Bill Jordan says restoration is the only approach to ecological stewardship that will last in the long run, which is the only run that counts. Restoration assumes a heavy human hand, exactly something that rubs the nature-as-sacred camp the wrong way. Jordan proposes a metaphor for guiding ecology: community. One reason both "liberal" and "conservative" politicians and activists scorn restoration ecology is because we hate community. We like having friends, but true community is very costly, an observation in line with scripture. True community goes against sinful nature, and requires society's full efforts to avoid disintegration.
Jordan lists four stages of a human's community involvement in life. These four struck me as very important for understanding life, but less important for building ecological principles:
1. I am not God. (Some people never figure this out)
2. Get a Job. (We all need to contribute to the world)
3. Giving Gifts. (Giving connects others to us)
4. Receiving Gifts. (Receiving connects us to others)
This one surprised me. How is receiving a greater communal than giving? It's a simple answer that is changing my life: receiving a gift binds us to someone else, while giving a gift only binds others to us. As long as we only give and never receive, no one has any claim on us and we retain absolute control over the relationship.
The Sunflower Forest is a science book that taught me more about community than many books ostensibly about community. It's also an insightful, if a little "out there" treatise on restoration ecology. The lessons are profound, but the policy recommendations - a debate within a narrow field of eco-philosophers - will date very quickly.
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Should be a classic, May 2 2011
By Todd J. Levasseur - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Sunflower Forest: Ecological Restoration and the New Communion with Nature (Hardcover)
This book is ambitious, broad in scope, interesting, and well written. Jordan advances a new theory about shame and eco-ritual that needs to be taken seriously by everyone from policy makers, ecophilosophers, educators, ecologists, and farmers. There is a lot of depth here and new terrain is covered, and it is covered with humility and clarity. Worth the read, and then pass it along.