Review
Wang's book, in addition to offering a general sketch of the history of the Chinese community in New York City, makes an important attempt to compare the experiences of Chinese Americans with that of Italian Americans. Wang sets out to provide a different analytical approach by examining the similarities and differences between Chinese and Italian immigrants in New York City. In doing so, he provides a fine survey of the literature on these subjects and some interesting discussions. Wang's open-mindedness and efforts to connect the study of Chinese American history to that of the other ethnic groups is admirable. (
Journal Of American Ethnic History )
This is an important contribution to understanding the Chinese American experience. (
The Journal Of American History )
Surviving the City makes many significant contributions to American ethnic studies. Wang has offered a new set of origins and conceptual tools to work with so that scholars of Race and Ethnicity can now remake not only Chinese American history, but perhaps all ethnic American histories. (
International Migration Review )
Surviving the City is a tightly focused case study that could work well as a reading in upper-level undergraduate and graduate level courses. Scholars with an interest in New York City or the history of immigration in the U.S. society will also find this study well worth their attention. (
New York City History )
Tightly reasoned and stimulating to read, Wang's important book is accessible to general audiences and all academic levels. (
Choice Magazine )
Book Description
This innovative work explores the multifaceted Chinese experience in New York City. Incisively questioning accepted wisdom and easy cultural assumptions, Xinyang Wang persuasively illustrates that economic forces more than racism influenced immigrantsO life decisions. Wang argues that rather than being passive victims, the Chinese were economic actors making rational choices for survival. Wang answers such questions as why for the first half of the century New York Chinese continued to live in white neighborhoods despite severe discrimination there, why they retained their group loyalties even at the expense of fighting discrimination, and why they chose not to join the established labor movement. The author shows how, with the rise of an enclave economy in the 1950s, the New York Chinese began to make different survival choices. Now more took up residence in Chinatown, loosened the bonds of regional and kinship networks, and unionized. By avoiding strictly culturalist explanations and incorporating a comparative analysis of Italian immigrants in the city, Wang erases long-standing stereotypes about the Chinese American experience and brings it into the mainstream discourse on AmericaOs immigrant history.
