Symphony No.10 has been added to your Cart
+ CDN$ 3.49 shipping
Used: Very Good | Details
Sold by usedsalesca
Condition: Used: Very Good
Comment: All Discs are inspected and guaranteed. All dispatched with 1 - 3 working days from the UK
Have one to sell? Sell on Amazon

Symphony No.10

Price: CDN$ 15.37 & FREE Shipping on orders over CDN$ 25. Details
Usually ships within 2 to 5 weeks.
Ships from and sold by Amazon.ca. Gift-wrap available.
27 new from CDN$ 8.03 11 used from CDN$ 8.02

58th Annual GRAMMY Awards
Discover this year's nominees on CD and Vinyl, including Album of the Year, Artist of the Year, Best New Artist of the Year, and more. Learn more

Frequently Bought Together

  • Symphony No.10
  • +
  • Symphony No. 8
  • +
  • Shostakovich: Symphony No. 4
Total price: CDN$ 40.87
Buy the selected items together

Product Details

  • Performer: Petrenko; Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra
  • Composer: Shostakovich Dmitri
  • Audio CD (Nov. 16 2010)
  • Number of Discs: 1
  • Label: Ncl
  • ASIN: B0040SOKTK
  • Average Customer Review: Be the first to review this item
  • Amazon Bestsellers Rank: #34,356 in Music (See Top 100 in Music)
  •  Would you like to update product info, give feedback on images, or tell us about a lower price?

Product Description

In the wake of his Naxos recording of Shostakovich's Symphony No. 8 (8.572392), hailed as 'yet another Petrenko performance to join the greats' (BBC Music magazine), comes this much-anticipated interpretation of Shostakovich's massive Symphony No. 10, which ranks among his most important and consistently popular works. Branded with his musical monogram DSCH, it embarks on a profoundly personal journey from fearful brooding to thunderous triumph. In 2010 Vasily Petrenko was named Male Artist of the Year at the Classical Brit Awards, a testament to his galvanizing achievements with the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic. Listen to an interview about the new recording here:

Customer Reviews

There are no customer reviews yet on Amazon.ca
5 star
4 star
3 star
2 star
1 star

Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)

Amazon.com: HASH(0xa8cf65e8) out of 5 stars 23 reviews
61 of 62 people found the following review helpful
HASH(0xa918efb4) out of 5 stars Shostakovich - sunny side up Nov. 16 2010
By Steen Mencke - Published on Amazon.com
Format: Audio CD
The tenth is arguably one of Shostakovich' finest works, continuously battling the fifth for the gold in the popular vote, and over the last fourty-odd years a multitude of first-class performances have found their way to the mediums of LP and later CD. It is a symphony that demonstrates both great depth of emotion and at the same time the expressivety of a marching brass band (in short, Shosta at his best), and, composed in the exuberant months following Stalin's death in March 1953, it occupies a pivotal position in the oevre of the composer (for more about the symphony per se, see also my review of Semyon Bychkov's exemplary recording for AVIE).

Vasily Petrenko, by now a Shostakovich interpreter to be reckoned with, handles every note to perfection, and what a first-class orchestra the RLPO has become over the last decade! Every instrument group, sounding smooth as silk, shines like a midsummer sunrise and even the subtlest phrasing is in perfect sync. This is praise indeed - but therein, oddly enough, lies also my only real reservation when comparing this recording to others of equal standing.

Many years ago a critic for Gramophone magazine, when reviewing a Mahler recording by Leonard Bernstein, could not help complaining that once more the conductor just simply had to squeeze that last drop of neurotic angst out of the music, and this technique was beginning to feel a bit "over-done". He may have had a point, but once you've grown accustomed to heart-on-sleeve interpretations the "straight-up stuff" tends to come across as just a tiny bit bland (or under-salted, to stay in the technical language of the kitchen), and, to me at least, there was a spot or two in Petrenko's reading that was just a tad too straight forward. One example is the little valse grotesque of the third movement (at 7'52); this is played technically without fault but with the very stiffest of upper lips. If you turn to say Solti's recording (Decca 433 073-2) his sudden drop of pace from waltz to slightly wobbly Ländler turns the dance into something like a struggle to get out of the quicksand of a seemingly paralysed everyday life. Or Sanderling's (Naïve V 4973 live) all but impossible accelerando in the same place, that introduces a quasi-schizoid slapstick element to the otherwise grey and icy movement. Little things like that can make quite a difference. The allegro (rather trying for presto furioso, as seems to be the trend these days) is extremely effective, but again Sanderling achieves a somehow more biting - or menacing - effect at a slower tempo. All in all, I miss something a bit angular (or even abrasive) in this performance, but for that to make its mark maybe the conductor had to be there in the old USSR when the going got rough - like Mravinsky or Sanderling or Bychkov; or maybe he had to be very far away - like Karajan, who always, to my considerable surprise, did this symphony astoundingly well. For these isolated instances of "underkill" I should like to deduct about half a star, but as that is not possible and as my qualms are related mostly to personal taste, I'll let Petrenko have the full five. Everything else is just so infuriatingly (from a critic's point of view) well done in this recording.

The Naxos engineers, having hit the target spot on in Petrenko's recording of the Rachmaninov Symphonic Dances, again manage a sound that is both sumptuous and finely detailed with a nice sense of space around the orchestra, so full marks in that department. The unstopable second movement in particular comes across as the sonic equivalent of an onrushing train; put that in your stereo and smoke it!
32 of 32 people found the following review helpful
HASH(0xa918e888) out of 5 stars Absolute Best Nov. 22 2010
By KARL - Published on Amazon.com
Format: Audio CD
I have listened to many performances and recordings of the Shostakovich 10th since my initial encounters in the middle 1950s via Ancerl on Decca LP, and Mitropoulos on Columbia LP (this latter regarded at the time as a `demonstration quality' recording). However, no performance from then to now is the equal of this new one from Petrenko. In contrast to Karajan and others' versions, this brilliant performance SOUNDS like Shostakovich. It is thrillingly recorded. You owe it to yourself to hear it.
26 of 26 people found the following review helpful
HASH(0xa918ece4) out of 5 stars Excellent. Reminds me of my old Svetlanov one on LP Dec 23 2010
By Amazon Customer - Published on Amazon.com
Format: Audio CD
One of the records I treasured in my youth, and still haunts me today (I lost it somewhere years ago), was a Shostakovich 10th that I had on a Melodiya Angel LP with Yegeney Svetlanov conducting the USSR S.O. (Moscow). I've heard a number of fine recordings since (including Skrowaczewski), but none of them has erased the sound of that old Svetlanov one in my mind. This new recording of S10 with Valery Petrenko has THAT sound. Perhaps it's the air-raid siren oboes during the louder parts, or the fast vibrato during the fourth movement's big bassoon solo (some say that Shostakovich represents himself with the solo bassoon). Or, perhaps it's the rather expansive yet focused treatment of the first movement, only to be immediately followed by an outrageously manic performance of the "Stalin" movement. Regardless, I feel that my ship has finally come home with this new one. It's a bit hard to believe that such mature and thoroughly idiomatic Shostakovich could come from a conductor who never had to face the horrors and absurdities of Stalin's Russia, the way that Svetlanov, Kondrashin, Mravinsky, Rozdestvensky, and many others had to. But such is the way of music - it's completely free of politics and other subjective imprints. All one has to do is inform themselves of idiomatic performance practice, use a little imagination of their own, and then somehow communicate those concepts to those who work with them (the orchestra, in other words). This is a great follow-up to Petrenko's equally fine performance of the Shostakovich 8th - an even better symphony, in my book (they're both great).
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful
HASH(0xa906a78c) out of 5 stars **** 1/2 A young maestro in full stride, falling just a step short of the summit Jan. 2 2011
By Santa Fe Listener - Published on Amazon.com
Format: Audio CD
I've been bowled over in concert by the highly gifted Petrenko, and his Liverpool musicians are passionately dedicated to him. For me, his best Shostakovich so far has been his revisionist view of Sym. 8, which was mesmerizing in its eerie, sensitive understatement. He applies the same restraint here, not as consistently but markedly so in the first movement, where the letdown in dramatic tension poses a problem for me. The great climax of this long movement, which at 22 min. dominates the whole work (the remaining three movements last 29 min.), is huge and cathartic. But what of the clarinet interludes, which are done so mildly? The soloist plays blandly, and when the Gramophone's ecstatic reviewer declares categorically that Petrenko's is the best recording since Karajan's, I wonder if he remembers the intensity and grip of Karajan's clarinetist.

After this minor disappointment, I sat up for the Scherzo, which Petrenko rips at a fast gallop, although he doesn't aim to make the music snarl in satiric or bitter fashion. Mravinsky and Karajan have little to fear here, yet in his own way Petrenko is hair-raising. The third movement Allegretto ushers us into the problematic second half of this work, risking serious anticlimax if the conductor cannot find a captivating mood for music that is banal on the surface. Petrenko starts off rather neutrally, but his refined phrasing and his ear for orchestral balance serve well as the movement unfolds. The Andante section that opens the finale is very sensitively done, with excellent work by the solo oboe, flute, and bassoon, who must carry everything by themselves against hushed strings in the background - this whole section is one of the most inspired in the Tenth.

Petrenko excelled in the gaunt final pages of the Eighth, and the finale's Allegro section, being very similar, brings out the best in him. He casts shadows evocatively, until the chirpy music opens a jack-in-the-box surprise - it alights on a ghostly carnival mood reminiscent of the haunted toy shop of the even more enigmatic Sym. 15. Petrenko knows how to handle this kind of music so that it never sounds trivialized but retains its strange merriment.

In the end, this isn't a towering recording if you know Karajan, Stokowski (in a Chicago Sym. commemorative box), Mravinsky, Mitropoulos or the darkest of dark horses, Frank Shipway, in a stunning reading with the Royal Phil. But the past is prologue, and on its own terms this is a very exciting performance, not nearly as revisionist as some of Petrenko's earlier Shostakovich yet undoubtedly impressive.
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful
HASH(0xa906a804) out of 5 stars Stunning, indeed the best Dec 20 2011
By Laszlo - Published on Amazon.com
Format: Audio CD
I felt so energized after listening to this performance that I sat to write this. I read, however, that others have shared my view, thus, I will mainly add my five stars to the average and leave some notes.
This is the best 10th I have ever heard (I have dozens in my collection). A Tenth for the 21st century, as Mravinsky, Ancerl and Karajan were for the 20th.
I'll merely point out the things that impressed me.
1. The recording is absolutely incredible! Every instrument's line perfectly audible, their balance outstanding. Kudos to the engineer.
2. What a superb orchestral the RLPO has turned out to be under Petrenko.
3. Listening to the Allegro (2nd movement) while driving; I almost had to stop the car (not the music!) The drive (no pun intended) and execution of this movement is just incredible (it is supposed to represent Stalin).
4. This recording earned accolades and prizes from Gramophone, and deservedly so.
5. If you want your Shostakovich raw and earthy, go to 20th-century versions. If you want it driven, angry, relentless, stay here.

Look for similar items by category