24 of 26 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Different tack than I expected..., Nov 15 2005
By Sean G "Sean G" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Synthetic Worlds: The Business and Culture of Online Games (Hardcover)
I expected something a little more "rigorous" from Dr. Ed. I believe though that he takes an excellent first swipe at virtual worlds.
For people already playing these games the first 50 or so pages are boring. But he obviously covers this material so that even lay people can quickly be brought up to speed on his other topics. He sometimes slips back into these rudimentary explanations but I believe it is an effort to help the larger market.
He covers a wide variety of topics in this book. Discussions of property rights within VR worlds, violence within VR worlds, and the actual value of VR money and items. The variety of topics leads to a slight rambling feel in the book and some thiness on the arguements. However, I thought everything was adequately covered. I was looking for something of a "truer" economic discussion of synthetic worlds but he teased me. He does write an explanation, and defense, of synthetic economies and problems within them. For me though, I thought this was going to be all 300 or so pages when it was just about 75.
If there were more books like this published I would have given him 3 stars but since this is going to be the start in a long, long, long series of books I will give him 4 for breaking ground. He probably should have milked the material for two books. :)
If you have play these games and have and a tidbit of economics in you then buy the book and enjoy. I am going to read his papers now in an effort to get that fix.
Sean
26 of 31 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
The New Face of Gaming explored inSynthetic Worlds, Oct 17 2005
By Robert E. Murena Jr. "tedmurena" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Synthetic Worlds: The Business and Culture of Online Games (Hardcover)
I first came across DR. Castranova after reading a paper he had written on the cost variance between male and female Avatars (characters) sold on Ebay for the game "Everquest". As a recovering ex-gamer I found this material interesting. Anyone who has ever played a game that is within a synthetic world should understand exactly how engrossing they are.
(A Synthetic World is a gaming landscape that is always running in which gamers can interact with each other and play within a virtual reality that has loose rules and the characters can nearly do whatever they want)
Dr. Castranova's book "Synthetic Worlds" explores the new technology of role playing games set within these virtual realities and what they mean to the players and to society at large. It all started in the later 90's when the video game classic Ultima was created as "Ultima Online". From then on there have been more and increasingly complex virtual world games including "Everquest" and "World of Warcraft". Gamers who want to have good characters in these games can play for many hours and build their warriors, mages etc into powerful players OR they can buy them on Ebay. This is one way in which the game world has real world implications. But on a deeper note it seems that gamers many of whom put in many hours a day within these synthetic worlds, often seem to care more for their synthetic life than their actual one. There are several problems with this and while the majority of people can cope with the separation of synthetic and actual worlds there are a few that cannot. Either way these synthetic worlds have become a great new form of escapism that lets the user do things they could never do in a very real feeling way.
Castranova further looks into the video game industry and poses the question of what happens when the gaming company cannot make money on the game any longer and wishes to "pull the plug" on the synthetic world. Obviously people would be annoyed and he suggests that possibly the game could be turned over to the players but this too poses difficulties.
I found this book to be a very interesting read and as we spend more time in front of computer interfaces each day I think we can all learn something about they way we interact with technology from reading this book. Certainly reading about the gamers themselves is very enlightening and anyone interested in the way people escape will also find this an interesting read. I think anyone interested in sociology or technology will find this book worthwhile.
Ted Murena
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Eh...alright, Nov 9 2006
By Maverynthia - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Synthetic Worlds: The Business and Culture of Online Games (Hardcover)
it's good for what it is, though the author writes it as a term paper for college "This is what the chapter is about..." exactly like that. Lots of dryness there, lots of facts. It's also mostly focused on the Economy of and existing in MMO, not so much the culture people are thinking of (dating, avatars selection, gender bending, etc.) or how MMO's are ran as a buisness.