11 of 12 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Ghost story of an antiquary, Oct 16 2008
By Jay Dickson - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Man In The Picture (Hardcover)
Susan Hill's latest novella recalls the famous Edwardian ghost stories of M. R. James and the Benson brothers as much as her famous previous short novel THE WOMAN IN BLACK recalled the Victorian ghost stories of Charles Dickens, Wilkie Collins, Henry James and John Meade Falkner. We have here many of the more familiar tropes of M. R. James's ghost stories--tales within tales, multiple narrators, bachelor antiquarians in rooms at Oxbridge, and a woman possessed by a burning revenge--and in terms of atmosphere Hill is pretty faultless. But the novella leaves too much unclear in its telling. Although you want a certain amount of mystery preserved at the end of a ghost story, there's just too much muddled at the end of this to really get the effects Hill strives for--so while most of the story is quite a page turner, the final narrative section leaves you a bit unsatisfied.
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Read in a thunderstorm and not scared, Mar 30 2009
By Meredith Fredericks "bportgirl" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Man In The Picture (Hardcover)
This is a well-written (until the end) little trifle, but that's all it is. I like the style, but it isn't nearly as scary as the jacket would have you believe. In fact, I read it in a thunderstorm last night -- yes, it's a very quick read -- and, upon finishing it, went down to my dark, stone basement to do the laundry. I agree with the other reviewers: It plays like that old TV episode with Roddy MacDowell and the changing picture (Was that on Dark Shadows?), but the TV version was far scarier. Still, a quick, fun read.
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
What a strange little book!, Dec 28 2009
By Yolanda S. Bean - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Man In The Picture (Hardcover)
I enjoyed this novella, but I really wish that the idea had been expanded upon... it just seemed like there could have been so much more to this story. It did seem like a very classic type of ghost story - the sort to be further condensed and shared at sleepovers and camp fires. All in all, it was intriguing and enjoyable. I would definitely read something else by this author. Her writing really had a sort of timeless quality to it and the premise was interesting.