Talking About Detective Fiction Hardcover – Dec 1 2009
|New from||Used from|
No Kindle device required. Download one of the Free Kindle apps to start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, and computer.
To get the free app, enter your e-mail address or mobile phone number.
“She writes so wittily and with such authority that this lucid little book may well join the handful of classic essays on the genre.”
— The Globe and Mail
“A task she is more than capable of handling. . . . Her writing shows a vast knowledge and abiding love for the genre she describes. . . . Talking About Detective Fiction is fascinating. It’s as rich in characters and literary detail as the novels that have made James famous.”
— USA Today
“It is P. D. James’s longevity, as well as her serene intelligence, that makes this book especially noteworthy and enjoyable. . . . If you want to extend your own reading, discover new authors or clarify your thoughts, this is an excellent way to do so.”
— The Independent
“Who better to ask about the reasons for the ever-increasing popularity of crime fiction than one of the genre’s most revered practitioners? . . . James is as clear-eyed as her hero [Adam Dalgliesh]. . . . A pioneer among those mystery writers who make their readers see the world more clearly even as they try to pull the wool over their eyes.”
“A short book, but it has heft, and little wonder, given Lady James’s literary mastery and deep familiarity with her subject. . . . Her literary sensibility—calm observation and exact description—is on ample display in Talking About Detective Fiction.”
— Wall Street Journal
About the Author
P. D. James is the author of 20 books, most of which have been filmed for television. Before her retirement in 1979, she served in the forensics and criminal justice departments of Great Britain's Home Office, and she has been a magistrate and a governor of the BBC. The recipient of many prizes and honors, including being inducted into the International Crime Writers Hall of Fame, she was created Baroness James of Holland Park in 1991. In 2000 she celebrated her 80th birthday.See all Product Description
Top Customer Reviews
This relatively brief book (about 196 pages of text - the book dimensions are small and the pages have large margins all round) touches on a broad range of considerations, including the origins of detective fiction and how it was prefigured in Dickens, Austen, Bronte and others as well as the history of the genre through the Victorian and Edwardian ages as well as the "golden age" between the wars and immediately following WWII, up to the present day. James also discusses briefly the major differences between detective fiction on either side of the Atlantic, comparing the "hard boiled" heroes (or anti-heroes) of the American authors with the tidy and familiar heroes, and their "Watsons", of the English "golden age" authors, with stories often set in an idyllic and largely imaginary iconic English country side. Also touched upon is the changing psychology between the "golden age" and the present one, as well as the huge shifts in cultural climate in which detective fiction nevertheless still finds a prominent place. James deals with many more aspects of the genre that I won't get into here. However, for the reader who is looking for an in depth, scholarly and comprehensive work on detective fiction, this is not it. While there is obviously much thought, reflection and broad reading behind it, by James's own admission, this is not a penetrating critical or exhaustive work.Read more ›
Originally published in England, most of the examples come from English literature (as opposed to American) and many of them are from books that I enjoyed as I grew up. Seeing them critiqued gently, affectionately but with a mind sharp as a scalpel is a rare treat.
The writer shows how they fit and illuminated the sense and mores of the time they were written. She slices and dices her topic with logic and thoroughness. The icing on the cake (sorry about all the food references - I must be hungry) are the well-chosen cartoons that illustrate most of the chapters.
If you are an Anglophile who loves the mystery genre, this book is for you. Read and enjoy!
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
This is what happens with P.D. James marvelous book. James is the queen of modern detective fiction, certainly, without any doubt, one of the royal family.
James states that mystery novels are composed of several basic elements: a crime, usually murder; a small circle of suspects, each having a motive to commit the crime; opportunity; a detective; and a solution that is inserted into the novel with deceptive cunning, but with fairness. The last point means that readers will realize when they hear the detective's solution that the solution fits what was disclosed previously in the novel.
James describes the differences between detective stories, thrillers and horror tales. Each genre has its own elements and its own purposes. A reader who knows the elements and purposes can appreciate the tale better. Detective stories, she writes, do not, or at least should not, investigate a murder or another crime; nor should they dwell on the bizarre happenings; they should focus on the tragic fate of the people involved.
James describes the history of detective fiction and introduces her readers to over a dozen of the best writers, generally focusing on British women. She gives special attention to Agatha Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers, Margery Allingham and Ngaio Marsh. She discusses the strength and weaknesses of these stories, their history, psychology and sociology.
James is not reluctant to reveal her opinions on the authors she dislikes. She describes Agatha Christie disparagingly. She states that her style is neither original nor elegant and she is not a very good writer. Her characters are pasteboards. James writes cleverly: "Perhaps her greatest strength was that she never overstepped the limits of her talent."
Scholars, she reveals, differ as to who wrote the first detective story. Some say it was Caleb Williams in 1784. Some insist it was Edgar Allan Poe who invented the genre in1841 with The Murder in Rue Morgue. Others vote for Wilkie Collins' The Moonstone in 1860. James prefers the latter. She tells the fascinating true story that prompted The Moonstone.
James identifies the first great detective as the iconic Sherlock Holmes who Conan Doyle introduced in 1887 in A Study in Scarlet. Doyle was so enthralled and naïve that he sold his rights to this masterpiece for twenty five pounds.
James awards second place to G. K. Chesterton who began his Father Brown series in 1911. The tales were so delightful that few readers realized that they were never told the priest's first name.
James' book addresses many interesting questions. Why do some critics disparage some or all detective stories? What about these books attracts readers? Can people read detective stories more than once with pleasure? Do Protestants enjoy the books more than Catholics? How do readers experience relief of tensions? Why do many people like to read these tension filled novels in bed before sleeping? How do today's detective stories differ from those written in the past?
Those readers who enjoy deductive fiction will enjoy James' perceptive descriptions of it written with the same verve that she employs in her dramas.
As one reviewer has noted, James is rather disparaging toward Christie, though this is nothing new for James, who has been rather disparaging toward Christie for decades now. What is new is that James admits rereading some Christie and finding some of her works, like A Murder Is Announced, better than she recalled. One wishes James had gone back and read, say, Five Little Pigs, And Then There Were None, Endless Night or The Hollow; she might have altered her assertion that Christie simply creates pasteboard characters in whom the reader can have no possible interest apart from their contribution to the puzzle. Christie's continued great sales decade after decade would suggest that many readers are finding something in her books besides puzzles, for many ingenious puzzler contemporaries of Christie's have been forgotten. In Five Little Pigs, for example, Christie clearly has moved closer to a novel of character while at the same time providing readers with a teasing puzzle. Endless Night, published late in Christie's life, actually is more a "crime novel" in the modern mold. Even some of what are commonly seen as her pure puzzles, such as The Murder of Roger Ackroyd and The Murder at the Vicarage, are village satires with clever first person narration. And of course many of her "mere puzzles," like The ABC Murders, are sheer brilliance. And dare I say that Hercule Poirot and Miss Marple, mannerisms and all, are more memorable characters than James' poet-policeman, Adam Dalgleish? Time will tell on that one ultimately, but in the meantime to conclude that Christie was not an innovator and that she had no interest in exploring her chosen genre seems simply wrong to me.
It should surprise no one who has followed James' career over the decades that she is a great admirer of Dorothy L. Sayers, long the pretender to Christie's throne. James not only admires Sayers' novels (though she criticizes some of the murder methods in them on grounds of realism), she emulates Sayers as a critic, elevating, as Sayers did, the Victorian sensation novels of Wilkie Collins as the model for the modern detective novel. Like the novels of Sayers, the novels of James have grown longer and longer over the years, with more and more emphasis on character study and description of place and less and less emphasis on clever puzzle mechanics. James sees this "realism" as making the detective novel stronger, something closer to the mainstream novel. Some mystery fans might feel that James' later books have become too much like mainstream novels and prefer earlier ones where the author placed more emphasis on providing her readers with a clever puzzle. Still, there is no question but that the Baroness remains, at nearly ninety years of age, an articulate and charming writer in "Talking About Detective Fiction"; and her admirers should enjoy this little book.
Brava, Dame James!
Except for a chapter on Hammet and Chandler of the American hardboiled school and some admiring, but brief, tips of the hat to Sara Paretsky, Georges Simenon and Henning Mankell, James concentrates her attention on her fellow Brits--Conan Doyle, Chesterton, Crispin, Christie, Sayers, Allingham, Marsh, Rendell and others--with particular emphasis on the so-called "Golden Age" when the plots were ingenious, the murders horrible and bizarre and the villains superhumanly cunning ... "not the days of the swift bash to the skull followed by sixty thousand words of psychological insight."
She also looks at how the genre has evolved since the Victorian age and why it has remained so popular. Then, perhaps most interesting of all, she takes us inside the writing process for a closeup look at some of the challenges peculiar to detective-story writing in general and to her own Adam Dalgliesh novels in particular. Most illuminating.