Most helpful customer reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Obsession is universal, Jan 23 2004
This review is from: The Big Year: A Tale of Man, Nature, and Fowl Obsession (Hardcover)
To categorize "The Big Year" as simply a birding book is to sidestep the universality of this crisply written narrative. Three men spend 365 days to satisfy a burning desire to observe more species of birds than anyone else in North America. The ultimate prize is no more than bragging rights and a place in the record books. This is obsession, nothing more or less, at its finest. How many people are actually able to pursue their dreams? Going after a big year record takes the willingness and ability to hop a plane at a moment's notice, to travel to the kind of locales that people a little less loony would eschew, to spend copious amounts of time and money pursuing birds who very well might not be there by the time you arrive. Obmascik captures the whole picture in a lively book that reveals the occasionally desperate spirit of the competition, the nature of the competitors and, with finely researched science and historical writing, enough background information to help the new initiate understand just why this particular sport is interesting and how it came to be. This isn't simply a book for birders. It's an actively written account that transcends birding, one that offers up a unique slice of humanity to the interested reader.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
The Obsession of Birding, Jun 29 2004
This review is from: The Big Year: A Tale of Man, Nature, and Fowl Obsession (Hardcover)
Mark Obmascik has documented the "Big Year" of three extreme birders - Sandy Komito, Al Levantin and Greg Miller - as they try to beat a record and each other during 1998. This is more a sporting competition than natural history or science. They could just as easily had been train spotting for the largest number of different boxcars. The goal is of course to record the largest number of bird species seen in one year and they have a tough standard to play against. James Vardaman had recorded 699 birds in 1979, Benton Basham had seen 711 in 1983, Komito himself had gotten 721 in 1987, and Bill Rydell had gotten 714 in 1992. In 1998 all were trying to beat 721 and all were unbelievably driven. I won't tell you who won, but it certainly is a remarkable tale indeed! As a sometimes birder who is a professional biologist I understand the thrill of the chase and at least these listers are not killing their quarry. However, I am a bit astonished at the amount of money and time some of these extreme birders will spend to get over 700 birds on their list in a year. I have only about 250 birds on my life list (I'm not against listing) and I doubt that I will ever make 500 for my life. The story of their competition to reach over 721 birds in a single year is gripping, but I tend to agree with at least one of the left behind wives that they are also a little bit out of their minds. Everybody has a right to follow their dream (as long as they don't hurt others in the process) and birding is relatively harmless. I personally would prefer to get to know the birds a bit better than that. Perhaps that is a bit of academic snobbishness, but it is also my individual taste. In any case I recommend this book to anyone who would like to try to understand the drive to record the maximum number of birds seen in a year.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
It's birding Jim, but not as we know it!, April 4 2009
This is a book about obsession. Mark Obmascik tells the story of three birders - Greg Miller, Sandy Komito and Al Levantin - who take this most mild-mannered of hobbies to a new level in their desire to smash the existing record for a Big Year. A Big Year is a single year in which a birder aims to see as many north American birds as possible and in 1998, the number to beat was well over 700. There are no prizes, no huge international recognition, no kudos or accolades beyond obscure birding circles...no reason to do this...unless you're obsessed by birds. The exploits of these three guys are more of an extreme sport than the genteel pastime involving binoculars and sanwiches that birding is usually considered to be. These guys are prepared to charter helicopters to fly snowy peaks after Himalayan snowcocks, throw up over the back of ocean-going vessels to chase pelagic birds that never come to shore, yomp across frozen mud in freezing sleet on the remote island of Attu to see rarities blown off-course by winter storms, and canoe through alligator-infested swamps after flamingos. It's birding Jim, but not as we know it! The book is easy to read. Obmascik has stuck a good balance between drawing portraits of the three men, providing details about the birds and the locations they are found and he doesn't over-emphasise the lunacy of the pursuit...he doesn't need to! I'm only a on-off, kitchen-window kind of a birder but I enjoyed this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|