Most helpful customer reviews
2.0 out of 5 stars
Repetitive, unorganized, unthoughtful, Jan 25 2004
This review is from: The War on the Bill of Rights--and the Gathering Resistance (Hardcover)
I usually do not write reviews but I needed to share my thoughts on this book. First off I bought it because I'm very interested in this topic and have enjoyed similar books in the past, however this book was not that good. The book just does not have enough information to be a book!!! The author, while he is respected (in some circles) he just seems to repeat himself over and over again in order to fill the pages! It is so unorganized that it's got 35 chapters in 160 pages!!! Did you hear that, that's about 4 pages a chapter, and that gets so annoying because nothing is tied together, just repeated in the next chapter. The information is also just terrible, it's message board info, not material for a book, let me explain: most of the text is actual clips and quotes from other news sources like the New York Times! It just ends up being a book of other people's ideas about this. Not much originality at all. I did give it 2 stars because this is an important topic and I'm glad Hentoff is writing about it but it was just too forced and felt like he wrote it fast and didn't read the final copy!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
A MUST FOR REPUBLICAN/DEMOCRAT/INDEPENDENT!!!!!!, Jan 5 2004
This review is from: The War on the Bill of Rights--and the Gathering Resistance (Hardcover)
I hate writing reviews, but here's one for this book. I picked it up over holidays and read it in a few days. The book summarizes various violations to the Bill of Rights focusing on 1st and 4th amendments. It asks the so called "unpatriotic" questions, and thus exposing many things that are overlooked by mainstream media and consequently majority of Americans. Hentoff might as well send his book to all of the senators save Russ Feingold who was the only one to dissent on USA PATRIOT Act pushed so hastily by the Justice Department a month after 9/11. I don't care who you are a Republican, a Democrat, or an independent; you should always ask questions! Don't let anybody tell you that questioning your commander in chief is unpatriotic! America was born out of dissent. America should always question their leaders' decisions; that is what makes this country so great-the ability to do so. Read this book and after do not just put it down, but make your phone call, email your senators/representatives and let them know: YOU WANT YOUR RIGHTS BACK!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
An essential work for today's times, Dec 29 2003
This review is from: The War on the Bill of Rights--and the Gathering Resistance (Hardcover)
This work is not nearly as disorganized as the Amazon.com review would suggest, but would have gotten five stars if an editor had tightened it up a bit. Nat Hentoff offers a succinct and revealing view of the 2001 "Patriot Act" the Bush II administration rushed through congress. In many cases the provisions of this law come in direct conflict with several of the first ten amendments and give our government, specifically the executive branch, frighteningly broad powers over the citizenry it is supposed to serve. Particulary scary is the President's new power to hold people indefinately without charging them, without access to attorneys and without the knowledge of anyone, including their family. The comparisons to Abraham Lincoln's suspension of the writ of habeous corpus during the Civil War are inevitable. However, the strugle to hold our country together had a distinct end, which is something the current administration's war on terror lacks. The executive branch may hold this power forever. Mr. Hentoff extends his analysis to "Patriot Act II" which has not yet been passed, but could grant this power against U.S. citizens. He examines other portions of the bills which allow the siezure of property merely on suspicion, rather than reasonable evidence and the installation of the "magic lantern" into peoples' computers, allowing government agencies to track all activity without their knowledge. Your records from public libraries and booksellers may be seized and examined not only without your knowledge, but the acts make it illegal for these organizations to tell you the records have been accessed. The U.S. government is slowly removing many of the protections that make the United States unique and free. As quoted from the third season of The Simpsons, "The price of freedom is eternal vigilance." This book arms you with the knowlege to help protect your freedoms. It is a quick and gripping read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|