4.0 out of 5 stars
The Bourne Legacy, Feb 25 2005
This review is from: The Bourne Legacy (Hardcover)
Lustbader's Bourne Legacy is an excellent page turner in the Ludlum tradition. It's exciting plots and twists have kept me reading well past my normal bedtime. My one regrett is the early demise of Alex & Mo but unfortunately this is required for the plot line of the story.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Not Ludlum, but OK..., July 18 2004
This review is from: The Bourne Legacy (Hardcover)
If you're new to the Bourne universe then you MUST go back and read the series in order first (and no, having seen the movie doesn't count, since it has nothing WHATSOEVER to do with the series.) If you're an old Ludlum hand, then you want to know how this compares to the originals. The bottom line is that Lustbader is no Ludlum, but since Ludlum's own work was somewhat variable, LEGACY falls about halfway along spectrum.
On the positive side, Lustbader's plotting is quite good and this one is right up there with the best Ludlum. On the other hand, the writing is wooden at times and full of cliches, the torture scenes are disturbingly graphic (well beyond anything Ludlum ever wrote), and the suspension of disbelief required is (at least for me) problematic.
Lustbader gives the character Khan apparently greater powers than even Bourne (whose abilities already strain the limits of credulity) and even if one accepts the usual Ludlum conspiracy motivation zeitgeist, in this book there are a lot of loose ends, unbelievable coincidences, miraculous recoveries and escapes, unrealistic details both technical and political, and lack of back-story motivation for the villain that leave one somewhat unfulfilled. It is also a little too 'cinematic' for my tastes, with much of the book obviously written to lay the groundwork for a future film (distinct car chase, fight and explosion scenes that are more Bruckheimer than Ludlum.)
Perhaps my biggest regret is that, in what I assume is a deliberate move to make the series his own, Lustbader starts off by discarding the previously integral Conklin and Panov, and very publicly burning the Bourne/Webb secret identity. In the real world, after the events depicted in this book Webb would never again be able to walk out of his house without being followed by the press, let alone get involved in undercover skullduggery. This book, then, would only appear to make sense if Lustbader is intending to take the future series off in a different direction.
All in all, however, I give LEGACY four stars, and I will read the next one. I'm glad that the series is being picked up by a name writer as with Flemming's Bond series (instead of the unfortunate, ghosted, "completed by" or "together with" sequels such as the Gayle Lind stuf.) I only hope that in future novels Lustbader will continue with the good plotting while staying away from the gratuitous violence and implausibilities displayed in this one. Bottom line: the new kid shows promise [grin].
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
WOW Pleasant suprise, May 3 2006
Mustsay I was very suprised with this book. Being a real Ludlum fan who's read ALL of his books (new, old, everything) I wasnt even about to give this one a chance, thinking van Lustbader would try, and fail to continue the Bourne Series....boy was I wrong. The style is a little different of course, but he does an amazing job of keeping this series alive. I was on the edge of my seat throughout most of the book, and when the ending came along I was almost brought to tears. He's done Ludlum proud with Legacy, and I would have to rank this as #2 in the 4-part series. Still smiling from the ending, I could not think of a more fitting way to finish off the Bourne Series.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No