13 of 13 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent but Incomplete, Oct 19 2005
By R. W. Levesque - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Cold War: A Military History (Hardcover)
The book is a series of articles by many prominent modern historians and it begins at the beginning (a very good place to start) of the Cold War with an article entitled, "The Day the War Started."
Unfortunately, the book essentially ends in the early 1980s with, "The War Scare of 1983." What this means is the book does not consider the last years of the Cold War or how it ended. Another missing piece is that, other than the first series of articles on the war's beginnings and the more well known aspects of the Cold War such as the Cuban Missile Crisis and Berlin, the focus of the book is on the Korean and Vietnam Wars. It ignores other aspects of the Cold War such as our military involvement in Central America throughout the 1980s, the whole issue of brush fire wars in Europe's former colonies in which one side or the other was supported by the US or USSR, and the bipolarization of mid-level conflicts, such as in the Middle East, where, again, the US and USSR supported opposing sides. These missing aspects are not trivial in the context of the Cold War.
Having said that, I'm glad I bought the book, and I've already recommended it to others. It's impossible to not get a lot out of a book that includes articles by the likes of Williamson Murray, John F. Guilmartin, Jr., Douglas Porch, Stephen E. Ambrose, Victor David Hanson, and far more. But, in the end, it is incomplete - hence the three stars.
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Treasure Trove of Cold War Experiences, Sep 11 2005
By Steve Iaco - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Cold War: A Military History (Hardcover)
This is a fascinating anthology of essays, a rich treasure trove of Cold War experiences told by leading historians. Some events chronicled here are well known -- the Berlin Airlift, Cuban Missile Crisis, Truman's cashiering of MacArthur, Dien Bien Phu, etc. -- while others this reader learned about for the first time. For example, an uprising of North Korean and Chinese POWs at Koje-do; the Chinese Communist assault on the British frigate Amethyst in 1949, or CIA efforts -- soon compromised -- to tap Soviet telephone lines by digging a tunnel in East Berlin.
The collection of 27 essays begins with the 1946 showdown with the Soviets over their ambitions in Turkey. James Chace contends the Cold War started on August 19 of that year, when Truman sent a naval task force to Istanbul in response to Stalin's attempt to establish naval bases in the Dardanelles Strait. In the final essay, Williamson Murray examines Soviet military planners' strategy for invading central Europe, which came to light after the Berlin Wall's collapse. Instead of sending their tanks through the Fulda Gap and into West Germany, as widely anticipated, Soviet planners envisioned unleashing 300 to 400 nuclear missiles on Western Europe as a prelude to a ground assault. Only the prospect of massive nuclear retaliation from the U.S., Murray says, dissuaded the Kremlin from acting on its generals' invasion plans.
Readers will draw their own conclusions about which essays are the most intriguing. Personally, I especially liked Tom Fleming's account of Matthew Ridgway Herculean efforts to turn the tide in North Korea, and Victor Davis Hanson's "revisionist" account of Curtis LeMay's career and contributions.
Whatever your personal preference, this anthology will prove satisfying for any reader with an interest in recent American history.
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Military History of a Time of Peace, Unless You Were There, Oct 12 2005
By John Matlock "Gunny" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Cold War: A Military History (Hardcover)
From the end of the Second World War until the collapse of the Soviet Union almost a half century later the two major powers in the world faced a kind of war. It was called the cold war because not much fighting occurred. To be sure, there was some in places like Korea, Viet Nam and Afghanistan. And there were some time where the two superpowers faced each other over loaded weapons such as Berlin and Cuba. But all in all, this was the longest time since the Roman Empire that the two strongest countries on the globe didn't go to war.
During much of this time the Military History Quarterly has provided a venue for the most prominent historians of our time to present articles on points of history as it was being lived. Robert Cowley is the founding editor of MHQ. In this volume he has selected articles from the Cold War period that serve to be a history of the Cold War written as it happened. The authors include some of the most prominent historians of that time, and some others that are not so well known but who provide an insight into the times.