3.0 out of 5 stars
Would Say Its Somewhat Biased, May 23 2012
This review is from: The End of Detroit: How the Big Three Lost Their Grip on the American Car Market (Paperback)
An interesting book without doubt. The author seems to have some grudge against the big three in Detroit. True the big three has had its share of problems and most were self-imposed. As it is now 8 years old some of the predictions she wrote about have not materialized. I think that the big three can now compete with the import market quite readily. Many of her facts are true but some are a bit distorted. Its interesting how she makes little of the Japanese recalls yet goes way overboard when the American cars have problems. This book was written before the massive Toyota recall. Nonetheless the history, albeit in bits and pieces, she writes about is interesting. There is a definite lean towards imports. Anyone considering buying an import instead of a domestic might want to read a newer book. I do know that the big three do not make a vehicle I'd want but then again neither do the Japanese. The Koreans are taking over the import market.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
2.0 out of 5 stars
It's ok, but bear with her if you can, May 17 2004
By A Customer
I must say, I'm not as good a writer as Ms. Maynard, but I think I actually may know more about the car business than she. In fact, if you're an enthusiast, you may very well know more than she does as well. The book is just fair. It gives some neat historical recounts on how the Japanese set up their operations in the US, and how their corporate cultures and history are in Japan. I must say, though, there were times when I just wanted to give up on this book. Why? Errors...this thing is full of factual errors. For example, she says that Nissan owns a large piece of Fuji Heavy Industries, the maker of Isuzu. This is not correct. Nissan does own a large piece of FHI (they were the largest shareholder before GM bought 50% of the company), but FHI makes Subaru, not Isuzu. They have ties to Isuzu, but the reason why Nissan owning FHI was an issue is because of the Subaru competition (Imprezza and Legacy go head to head with the Sentra and Altima). This specific point is discussed in the fabulous book "Turn Around" about Carlos Ghosn. There are other errors as well. Her recounting of timing is also often off in talking about when a certain vehicle was the top seller (Camry, Accord and Taurus discussion), and when each luxury marque was the top in the US.
Another knitpicky thing is that she uses the word "dwarfs" a lot. However, she flips it's meaning. Dwarfs means that something that dwarfs something else looks much smaller next to it (i.e. A dwarfs B, and A is smaller than B). Sometimes she uses it in this correct way, and other times she uses it to mean the thing that dwarfs the other thing is bigger (i.e. A dwarfs B, and A is bigger than B). As a writer, she should know what she's saying, but should certainly at the very least be consistent.
I would let the dwarfs thing go, but the automotive errors are not forgivable, and they smack you in every chapter. If she is wrong about so much in the auto industry, it's hard to accept her take in the book. I don't disagree with her notion, but, really, get some fact checkers, or get educated about your topic.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Sometimes, the truth hurts, Jun 6 2004
By A Customer
I found this book to be very readable and very interesting. In my opinion, the author offers an unbiased review of the Big Three and the UAW. I sympathize with the unions (I'm in one) but a different approach will be necessary to make the Big Three competitive with Detroit South. I can relate to her statements concerning the Big Three cars to the imports. I've found my European and Asian car far more ergonomically sound and reliable than my Ford Explorer. Sometime the truth hurts....
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No