2.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointingly bad, Oct 29 2006
This review is from: The Fan (Widescreen) (DVD)
I had high hopes for this film, as I love Lauren Bacall & Maureen Stapleton. And while they're both as good as they can be, nothing can save this film from the bad script, the choppy editing, and the strange leaps in logic and story.
I can't address some of the negative elements without spoiling the film, but I'll say that some the public occurences would never have taken place without someone getting caught, some of the lines are so stilted & stiff that, even when delivered well, sound hackneyed and trite, and a lot of the shots are drawn out with little apparent point. Additionally, there are other odd inconsistencies, like Bacall treating a police lieutenant as if she hadn't interacted with him before even though they'd seen each other the day before. Finally, as much as I love Bacall, she just *can't* sing. There are several musical numbers in the film (written by Marvin Hamlisch & Tim Rice, iirc), and while she can sassily speak her way through a song, the ballads are painful. I know she's won two Tony awards; she must have won them on the strength of her acting because her voice is awful.
And the end - ugh! Aside from the problems with staging in the end, it just sucks.
This film isn't as bad as, say, Hannibal, but it's a ship that's destined to sink.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
edge of your seat thriller, Jun 6 2004
This review is from: The Fan (Widescreen) (DVD)
I HAVE TO SAY, AFTER I SAW THIS MOVIE IN THE THEATRE , I LOOKED FOR IT EVERYWHERE !!! BECALL AND GARDNER ARE FANTASTIC . THEIR STAR POWER COMES THROUGH .I WAS ON THE EDGE OF MY SEAT .I WATCH THIS FILM OVER AND OVER , IT NEVER GETS OLD. YOU TRULY HAVE TO LOVE " OLD HOLLYWOOD " TO APRECIATE THIS MOVIE AS MUCH AS I . IT IS VERY MUCH WORTH TAKING A LOOK SEE.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
BACALL TRIES, FILM FAILS...., Nov 4 2002
This review is from: The Fan (Widescreen) (DVD)
I have always liked Lauren Bacall as a "tough dame" type actress and her gritty outspokeness off-stage. But this film was a mistake. Maybe in the hands of a better director it would have worked. Bacall tries to make the dilemma of an aging stage star terrorized by a psychotic stalker believable but everything is against her. She forges ahead with her "comeback" Broadway show even after several of those near and dear to her are either slashed to death or just slashed by the straight-razor weilding weirdo who sends her dirty "fan" letters. The facial slashing of poor Maureen Stapleton is downright ugly and repugnant. But it sure heals fast in time for the opening of Bacalls' show. No one could have healed that fast---the multiple slashes were DEEP. Bacall trudges through her stage show numbers surrounded by adoring male dancers. After all, Broadway has been called the Gay White Way and no aging diva would set foot onstage without adoring male dancers. James Garner is utterly wasted as her love interest. He seems to be in the movie just because the two are friends. At any rate, despite Bacall's formidable presence this is a tacky New York filmed slasher show that disappoints on all counts. Bacall deserved better than this.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No