Most helpful customer reviews
4.0 out of 5 stars
Slow but Entertaining Read, Feb 2 2012
This review is from: The Fathomless Fire (Hardcover)
Reason for Reading: Next in the series. The first book in this trilogy was published in 2008 and I read it at that time. That book had ended with the conclusion of it's main plot although leaving it open for a next book to carry on with an overall arching plot. I had basically forgotten about this series when I saw the second volume was finally out and vaguely remembering a fondness for the story decided to carry on with it. I barely remembered any of the plot of book one as I went into this but that was ok because this book starts off with a brief page and a half summary of book one and then throughout the story mentions events from book one to refresh the readers' memory. These bits certainly don't go into any great details, but are welcomed by a reader who was with the author four years ago for the first book. I had some issues with the first book and they've been solved this time around. Will is a much more fleshed out character and I've grown more fond of him. Again this is a typical high fantasy story with a quest and a motley cast of travelling companions. Joining Will is old friend Shade the wolf, and eventually Flinn Madoc the Dwarf but we have a new fun and interesting character in Balor the wildman. Once again, even though I enjoyed the story and characters, I did find it a slow read, like the first one and I find it hard to explain way, except perhaps the writing style. While I was hooked on the plot, I just didn't find it a page-turner. Wharton has created a unique world here in which Will Lightfoot can travel from his own Earth with the convenience that weeks on Earth are equal to about a year in the Story Realm allowing him much time to complete his adventures. This book doesn't have quite as satisfying an ending as book one did. Yes, the main subplot that runs through the volume is solved and comes to a conclusion but the over all story arch running throughout both volumes is more pronounced in this book and the final ending, while not being a cliffhanger, is indeed a foreshadowing of what is to come in the next volume. With this kind of ending I can only hope readers do not have to wait another four years for the next book! Recommended for those who like their fantasies to consist of a quest with evil vs good and a cast of characters such as dwarfs, wildmen, horsemen, mages, seers, etc.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Slow but Entertaining Read, Feb 2 2012
This review is from: The Fathomless Fire (Hardcover)
Reason for Reading: Next in the series. The first book in this trilogy was published in 2008 and I read it at that time. That book had ended with the conclusion of it's main plot although leaving it open for a next book to carry on with an overall arching plot. I had basically forgotten about this series when I saw the second volume was finally out and vaguely remembering a fondness for the story decided to carry on with it. I barely remembered any of the plot of book one as I went into this but that was ok because this book starts off with a brief page and a half summary of book one and then throughout the story mentions events from book one to refresh the readers' memory. These bits certainly don't go into any great details, but are welcomed by a reader who was with the author four years ago for the first book. I had some issues with the first book and they've been solved this time around. Will is a much more fleshed out character and I've grown more fond of him. Again this is a typical high fantasy story with a quest and a motley cast of travelling companions. Joining Will is old friend Shade the wolf, and eventually Flinn Madoc the Dwarf but we have a new fun and interesting character in Balor the wildman. Once again, even though I enjoyed the story and characters, I did find it a slow read, like the first one and I find it hard to explain way, except perhaps the writing style. While I was hooked on the plot, I just didn't find it a page-turner. Wharton has created a unique world here in which Will Lightfoot can travel from his own Earth with the convenience that weeks on Earth are equal to about a year in the Story Realm allowing him much time to complete his adventures. This book doesn't have quite as satisfying an ending as book one did. Yes, the main subplot that runs through the volume is solved and comes to a conclusion but the over all story arch running throughout both volumes is more pronounced in this book and the final ending, while not being a cliffhanger, is indeed a foreshadowing of what is to come in the next volume. With this kind of ending I can only hope readers do not have to wait another four years for the next book! Recommended for those who like their fantasies to consist of a quest with evil vs good and a cast of characters such as dwarfs, wildmen, horsemen, mages, seers, etc.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Unique World and Fantasy Quest, Feb 1 2012
By Nicola Manning - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Fathomless Fire (Hardcover)
Reason for Reading: Next in the series. The first book in this trilogy was published in 2008 and I read it at that time. That book had ended with the conclusion of it's main plot although leaving it open for a next book to carry on with an overall arching plot. I had basically forgotten about this series when I saw the second volume was finally out and vaguely remembering a fondness for the story decided to carry on with it. I barely remembered any of the plot of book one as I went into this but that was ok because this book starts off with a brief page and a half summary of book one and then throughout the story mentions events from book one to refresh the readers' memory. These bits certainly don't go into any great details, but are welcomed by a reader who was with the author four years ago for the first book. I had some issues with the first book and they've been solved this time around. Will is a much more fleshed out character and I've grown more fond of him. Again this is a typical high fantasy story with a quest and a motley cast of travelling companions. Joining Will is old friend Shade the wolf, and eventually Flinn Madoc the Dwarf but we have a new fun and interesting character in Balor the wildman. Once again, even though I enjoyed the story and characters, I did find it a slow read, like the first one and I find it hard to explain way, except perhaps the writing style. While I was hooked on the plot, I just didn't find it a page-turner. Wharton has created a unique world here in which Will Lightfoot can travel from his own Earth with the convenience that weeks on Earth are equal to about a year in the Story Realm allowing him much time to complete his adventures. This book doesn't have quite as satisfying an ending as book one did. Yes, the main subplot that runs through the volume is solved and comes to a conclusion but the over all story arch running throughout both volumes is more pronounced in this book and the final ending, while not being a cliffhanger, is indeed a foreshadowing of what is to come in the next volume. With this kind of ending I can only hope readers do not have to wait another four years for the next book! Recommended for those who like their fantasies to consist of a quest with evil vs good and a cast of characters such as dwarfs, wildmen, horsemen, mages, seers, etc.
|
|
|