Most helpful customer reviews
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great bookl, but not for the faint of heart., Feb 2 2004
I have to admit that this is my favorite Nicholson Baker book by far. It is positively obscene, so if that bugs you then skip this review and forget about reading the book. To everyone else: this is one of the funniest, weirdest and most endearing books I have ever read. It doesn't have a lot in the way of plot, but the theme and Baker's prose more than make up for it. As a previous reviewer mentioned, Baker has more words for the various parts of the female body than Eskimos have for snow. My favorite is "jamaicas", but I'm not telling what it means. If you like Baker's style (and I would say that this is closer in style to the Mezannine than Vox, minus the footnotes) then there's a lot to like about this book. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Stop, pause, wait, Mar 12 2004
This is probably my favorite book from Nicholson Baker, the modern master of minutiae. Mr. Baker has a gift for capturing the essence of habits, thoughts, reactions, and objects that are so small, so insignificant that most people don't ever notice them ... and yet when Mr. Baker puts them on the page, he gets it just right. None of the half dozen of so books I've read from Mr. Baker sound like much when the plots are summarized, and that is certainly the case with The Fermata. The book's story line is based on the ability of the 35-year-old narrator Arno Strine to somehow stop time, and most of the pages are used up with explorations of how he decides what he can and can't do while time is stopped. The unimpressive story line means that the value of the book depends almost entirely on Mr. Baker's ability to keep the prose engaging. Sometimes it doesn't work (as with his more recent effort Box of Matches) and sometimes it works well, as with The Fermata. As always, what holds it together when it works is Mr. Baker's memory for trivia, his intelligence, and his eye for detail: witness the title: "Fermata," the noun form of the word "stop" in Italian, is also a musical term that means holding a note longer than the time value -- a perfect name for a book with this kind of plot. Ultimately, my criticism of The Fermata is one shared by all of Mr. Baker's books and all literature based on prose rather than memorable plots or characters. In my mind, they're like the old cliché about Chinese food, which tastes great but leaves you hungry a few hours later. In the case of this book, the prose keeps the pages turning, but when you're through, very little of it sticks with you.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
not funny, nothing interesting to say, Jan 16 2004
Baker came up with a great premise, and a great theme but he just failed to tie everything together nicely. The book is almost totally devoid of humanity, except for a last minute attempt to provide the main charector some. It's hard to be funny when there's no life to your story. That doesn't even go into the fact that Baker seems to have no idea how to write a female charector, i mean i'm male but the way the women in this story acted and reacted was ludicrous. Baker goes off on long tangents frequently which are supposed to be amusing, but they just become tiresome. To see random tangents done right read The Tetherballs of Bougainville by Mark Leyner. Baker doesn't totally grasp what is funny thinking that bizarre sexual fantasies are amusing. I mean they are but only when they are ridiculous not disturbing. I must say though I wish I had this guy's powers, and yeah when I think about it I guess all I would is look at women with their clothes off, but at least my autobiography would be about something...like say a profound life lesson i learned because of my ability. So that my book you know, has a reason to exist.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|