23 of 30 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars
Paging Hope Brown!, Sep 22 2004
By Hans J. Wollstein - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The First Female Stars: Women of the Silent Era (Hardcover)
This, truly, is a bizarre book. For one thing, the dust cover promises far more than the text delivers. Among the actresses profiled, according to the cover flap, are Hope Brown (who? The name doesn't even appear in the index); Ina Claire, who did 2, count 'em, 2 silent feature films and is only fleetingly mentioned on a couple of pages; Asta Nielsen, who is nowhere to be found; Anna Q. Nilsson, who is given but a cursory nod on a single page; and Dorothy Phillips and Alice Terry, both briefly acknowledged on single pages. I had especially been looking forward to author Menefee's take on the long-forgotten Dorothy Phillips. Those actually profiled include Theda Bara, the Gish sisters, The Talmadges, and Maes Marsh and Murray, most of whom, by stretching it a bit, could be considered early screen stars. But hardly among "the first." Janet Gaynor, in contrast, didn't arrive until 1924 and didn't become a star until 1927. Not exactly a screen pioneer. As for the text itself, the profiles are competent but a bit on the dry side, and several of the actresses have recently enjoyed full-scale biographies by, ahem, more enterprising profilers. Strangely, Mr. Menefee fails to list Eve Golden's wonderful "Vamp: The Rise and Fall of Theda Bara" in his otherwise lengthy bibliography, nor has he apparently been moved by Charles Affron's solid "Lillian Gish: Her Legend, Her Life," indispensible sources on two of the profiled actresses. In contrast, I see no pressing need for the present volume, whose conclusions include some airy comparisons between the importance of the lost silent films of Pauline Frederick and the future renown of Meryl Streep's cinematic output -- or some such; Mr. Menefee's point remains a bit unclear, at least to this reader. So instead of the rather superfluous "The First Female Stars," I recommend the aforementioned biographies, as well as Jeanine Bassinger's "Silent Stars" and Anthony Slide's "Silent Players," both volumes that actually cover new ground. And, once again, who IS Hope Brown?
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Nice Primer For Those Interested In Early Female Stars, Dec 7 2010
By Gail K. Powers "Abra" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The First Female Stars: Women of the Silent Era (Hardcover)
The author David Menefee has a good track record when it comes to chronicling early cinema and its stars. Ths book
does a nice job of profiling a few of them. The actresses chosen run the gamut----the well-known Gish Sisters (Lillian was active in film and stage throughout a large chunk of the 20th century) through Mae Murray(whose career crashed and burned and who lived in obscurity for the rest of her life).
While this book isn't extremely detailed in terms of comprehensive infomation, it is interesting and informative and should be viewed as a good springboard for further investigation on the genre. My advice is that if you are looking for detailed profiles this most likely is not for you.
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
I hoped for so much more, Nov 11 2010
By Lew - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The First Female Stars: Women of the Silent Era (Hardcover)
I have recently become fasinated with everything from film's silent area, especially the queens of the screen, those remembered and many of those that have been forgotten. Whose films have been lost for all time. I was really hoping for a lot more from this book but I found it to be a dull read, and poorly written. I thought it would be a lot more meaty and it just wasn't. It was a good effort though, and I applaud the author for going into detail about actresses that have almost been forgotten.