28 of 30 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Heroes, Villains, and Dreamers, April 16 2011
By DC_Fan_52 "-Weasel!" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Floor of Heaven: A True Tale of the Last Frontier and the Yukon Gold Rush (Hardcover)
Pre-release customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program
I've never written a book review before, so excuse me if I'm not on par with the other reviewers. I'm a modern guy and I like TV more than anything, so my measure of a book is how engrossing it is and how much it manages to pry me away from the television. "The Floor of Heaven" is pretty damn good. The back of the book compares it to "a horseless-carriage episode of 24." I've never watched 24, but I can definitely see them squeezing one or two seasons out of this book for television.
What's hard is trying to criticize this book. It's based on a true story. So, I'm looking at how it's presented, and if it's a story worth listening to. The answer to both is, "Yes." First we're introduced to the three main characters a Cowboy, a Conman, and a Dreamer, and they are very interesting individuals. Once I was invested, I couldn't wait for all three to crash into each other in Alaska. There are a handful of really great tales inside, but the main story is the "Great Gold Robbery" in the middle of the book. That part is what peeled me away from the TV for the longest time. It's pretty ingenious how the thieves stole the gold, and tracking down the perpetrators has the detectives tossed around Alaska and in some tights spots.
"Is this book going to turn into Treasure of the Sierra Madre?" I thought it would, but no it doesn't. Greed plays only a tiny part.
I was going to give this book 4-Stars. I thought I'd learn about all the different techniques prospectors used for mining gold or how they survived in the wilderness. There wasn't much new to learn. I'm giving it 5-Stars, because Charlie Siringo is my new hero. He's not Batman, he's just a cowboy/detective with his wits, and he favors caution over resorting to violence. Though he's always willing to draw is big colt if he needs to.
The other two main characters are also real people with their own ambitions and flaws, so they don't drag down the narrative when they have their turn in the spotlight.
So, 5-Stars. Stolen gold and a cowboy hero. Based on a true story from the last American frontier. For adventure fans.
20 of 23 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Story was good, atmosphere not so much., April 8 2011
By Schuyler T. Wallace "Writer, traveler, retire... - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Floor of Heaven: A True Tale of the Last Frontier and the Yukon Gold Rush (Hardcover)
Pre-release customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program
Howard Blum is candid about his intent with the writing of The Floor of Heaven. In his note on sources he says he wanted to write a true story about the early days of the old west and of the far north. "True" is a key word here because stories of that period are notoriously embellished by participants and observers. Finding the truth in the accounts of the time is a treacherous journey. Blum knows this and realized from the outset that he would have to proceed cautiously. I believe he has assembled his material, carefully vetted it, and written his story as he intended it to be. It is fine investigative reporting.
The Floor of Heaven is subtitled as a true tale of the American West and the Yukon gold rush. It's an intriguing story of three men very different in mind-set and integrity who eventually are drawn together by their individual aspirations. It's a story of a hard-working miner who strikes it big and needs the protection of a dedicated detective from a ruthless robber and con-man. Blum puts it all together in a masterful, exciting book.
I got a true sense of the time frame. Even the font at the beginning of each chapter made me think "old west." The individuals were carefully crafted as genuine pioneer characters and the dialogue was authentic and believable. The events were familiar milestones in American history. It all came off believable, but I had a problem with the overall feel of the book.
The author didn't draw me into the grit and turmoil of the old west and early Alaska. When I read Jack London my hands and feet become icy, I feel cold snow on my neck, and I smell a wood fire and frying bacon. I see spreads of impenetrable forest, heavy snow, and frigid mountain peaks. I hear the tumble of wild water mingled with the sounds of wild animals and rowdy adventurers. My muscles ache from fatigue. I never got that with Howard Blum's story. It seems to me that his protagonists operated in a bland environment and didn't suffer or work hard enough to deserve their goals. There's no sense of hardship in their endeavors.
It could be argued that narrative history shouldn't include feeling or atmosphere. That's true about newspaper writing. But I'm the reader here and I want to be of part of the story. I want to experience it. My favorite narrative historical accounts included my participation. I was there. I suffered. I shared in the losses and the rewards. I read Mr. Blum's book with interest and admiration for his research, but I didn't get to go to the places and live with the characters he wrote about.
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Like reading Deadwood in print!, Mar 8 2011
By Wulfstan "wulfstan" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Floor of Heaven: A True Tale of the Last Frontier and the Yukon Gold Rush (Hardcover)
Pre-release customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program
I really enjoyed the Deadwood television series, and the Klondike and Deadwood have a lot in common. I also interested in Alaskan history as my Dad grew up in Alaska, so this book sounded interesting from the get-go. And- it certainly turned out that way!
Howard Blum, the author of "American Lightning: Terror, Mystery, the Birth of Hollywood, and the Crime of the Century", "The Brigade: An Epic Story of Vengeance, Salvation, and WWII" and others has decided to tell the story of the Klondike gold rush by focusing on three "real characters" of the "Old North".
Charlie Siringo is a old-school cowboy turned Pinkerton Detective. George Carmack is a deserter from the Marines who "went native". And Soapy Smith is a con man (fans of Deadwood will recognize Soapy as the guy who sells "Soap with a prize inside!") .
The author deftly entwines the three stories, showing how each man had his part in the Gold Rush. For example George was the first who panned the Bonanza gold, and made the first claim on that river of gold. Soapy Smith gets into and out of trouble, but then hits the "Big Time" running the boom town of Skagway.
Hard hitting, well researched, and full of action, this book would make another great Cable series, like Deadwood. Hollywood, are you listening?
One small quibble- in order to get us the full background on his three protagonists, the novel doesn't get to the discovery of Gold in the Yukon until we're more than 2/3rd through. However, don't worry, there's plenty of stuff to keep you turning those pages until then!