1.0 out of 5 stars
Should re-name the book, Jan 30 2012
By WaterPixie - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Frankenstein Syndrome: Ethical and Social Issues in the Genetic Engineering of Animals (Paperback)
This book is terrible. It's not about genetic engineering, it's about animal research issues (which I know are related, but he gives obscure examples that in no way relate to the topic in the title). What's worse, I was on his side, and I HATED this book!
He claims in the beginning that he will spend half the book on the pro, half on the con, and that's not what happened at all. He spent about 10% on the topic in general, 99% of which was on the con. In the pro arguments, he used the same examples he had already used in the con and then immediately shot them down again. Just repetitive and awful to read.
If you do choose to read this book (or you're forced to for some reason) be sure to understand these terms, as they pop up a whole lot:
intrinsically wrong (not what you think, apparently there are 3 definitions, which he lays out for you about 1/3 of the way through the book)
vis a vis
prima facie
The author is pretty stuck on himself. He writes about all the talks he's given, how he's convinced the masses unintentionally about the wrong-ness of things, just by being an excellent speaker. His writing has no direction or relation and he writes as if he's God's gift to the rights of research animals. Should rename the book: "How I, B. Rollin, made fantastic strides miles above anyone else in regards to the ethical treatment of research critters." Subtitled: "Oh, and I'll mention a few pages worth of 'the Frankenstein thing.'"