41 of 46 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Short and Sweet, July 10 2010
By GB - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Hegel Variations (Hardcover)
This book combines some very interesting insights and claims about the Phenomenology of Spirit with a short, lucid format - lucid if one is used to Jameson's long, sometimes baroque constructions. Despite its accessible length, the book can at times presuppose a surprising amount of familiarity with Hegel's book and the literature on it. Other times, however, Jameson slowly introduces a commentator, key claims, vocabulary, etc. in ways that are very accessible. As a result, in many ways it is an uneven read when it comes to accessibility. Those familiar with Hegel and such commentators as Kojeve will find it pleasantly breezy, with every few pages providing a very rich nugget of food for thought on many fronts philosophical, cultural, historical, political, and of course, scholarly. If one is already familiar with Hegel, I would highly recommend this quick read for its interesting insights into a Hegel who does not believe in teleology - in an ultimate moment of history, but rather one committed to the dynamism of human rationality, as each failed attempt of common sense and its derivatives struggles to rebound. In many ways, Jameson seems to argue that it is this struggle to rebound, not some ultimately derivative form of common sense (which Jameson identifies with Verstand), that constitutes Absolute Knowing.
4 of 7 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
read it or be left behind, Mar 17 2011
By barryb - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Hegel Variations (Hardcover)
Jameson does to Hegel, what the "liberation theologians" did to moltmann's theology of hope. Therefore it is a very important book to read for any Hegelian scholar. This short book will take a slow and careful reading. Not a breeze, thankfully. Jameson is well read and has covered all the critical work on Hegel over the past 30 years. He uses the current language employed by today's Hegelian academic circle. And he generates a few new "significant words" of his own as a contribution. The academic climate continues to change regarding Hegel, about every 10 years. You better read and assimilate this if you want to be on board the next 10 years.