Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
A descent into hell, May 15 2007
This starts out as a funny book; but, ultimately, it isn't. This is a very sad book. We witness Mr Leith descent into his own private hell bounded by his addictions to food, alcohol and drugs. His weight will mark the beginning of his way to recovery, and this is the very first part of the book, and here the author is at his best. The narrative is made of disjointed pieces of coke snorting, binge drinking, vomiting, passing outs, interspeced with parts of interviews (most notably with Dr Richard Atkins), impressions (some funny, some ironic), opinions, and self-questionning. It ends on an uplifting note thoughhope and happiness can prevail in the end nonetheless, or so it seems. Despite some flaws, I liked it a lot.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Inspiring!, Jun 8 2008
This book is funny, sad and inspiring. For anyone who is overweight, I think this book could be very helpful. It made me realize a lot about myself that I did not know, and sometimes that's all you need to start living a better life. Not just for food addicts either, it's an entertaining story for anyone. and to see how he's battled this addiction that is commonly not recognized as a serious addiction, is truly inspiring.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Here's the problem..., Jan 26 2006
By Huldren - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Hungry Years (Hardcover)
I don't hate this book, but it's not the book I thought it would be. From the review I'd read and from the title itself, I was expecting a book about food addiction. But it's not just about binge-eating, as William Leith is also heavily into coke, drinking and anything else that you might become addicted to (cell phones, casual sex). By the end of the memoir he seems to have become addicted to walking, though I'm not quite sure if we're supposed to think this is a positive thing or not. You could argue -- as Leith does -- that the basics of addiction are the same no matter what you are addicted to, and you'd probably be right. However, I still feel that snorting coke and drinking yourself unconscious is on a whole other level than unhealthy eating, because you need to cross a social threshold to do drugs. For me this threshold is very high, and that makes it difficult for me to grasp the kind of world where doing coke recreationally is normal, never mind doing it until you collapse. I was hoping to find a book about the love-hate relationship a binge-eater has with food, but Leith's memoir is more about how a traumatic childhood can trigger compulsiveness. The language itself is even a little compulsive, with repeated sentences like, "I am, and I am not;" "We are empty, and we are not empty." There are several lines in a row that begin with the word "And," and five or six chapters end with the same sentence, in order to drive a point home. All in all this is not a terrible book. It doesn't offer any final solutions, it's humorous and sometimes thoughtful, and with its bite-size chapters it's an addictive read. But it's not really a book about food addiction.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Smoothly-Written Chronicle of Addiction, Nov 10 2005
By Debra Hamel - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Hungry Years (Hardcover)
William Leith's The Hungry Years, written in smooth, stream-of-consciousness prose, is a chronicle of the author's addictions, principally to food but also to alcohol and drugs. Leith writes about bingeing and being fat (a word he injects into the narrative at every opportunity), about feeling fat even during his thin periods, about dieting--losing weight and gaining more back, losing and gaining. His history is punctuated by lapses into unthinking consumption, gluttony on a scale that may surprise his more abstemious readers. During the period covered in the book Leith is attempting to lose weight on yet another diet, this time the low-carbohydrate Atkins plan. While chronicling his progress and backsliding on Atkins Leith gives a fractured account of his life, which in turn illuminates his addictions: unhappy years in boarding school, a series of unhappy relationships. Throughout, Leith is searching for the underlying cause of his addictions: he is smart enough to recognize that whatever his current condition--fat or thin or drunk or not--however successfully he may be treating his symptoms, he is basically unhappy. However much he loses this time on Atkins, in other words, diet alone can't truly help him. In the course of writing this staggeringly personal, and sometimes amusing, account of himself, Leith wanders also into related topics. He writes about French fry production and celebrity diets (Robbie Coltrane, "Hagrid" in the Harry Potter films, will not appreciate his mentions here), about pain killers and plastic surgery. (Leith's graphic description of the last should dissuade any but the most intractably vain from undergoing elective procedures.) In the end Leith's various ruminations come together into a coherent whole. The book succeeds as a readable exploration of both the West's culture of consumption and its author's demons--wounded by book's end, if not yet slain. Reviewed by Debra Hamel, author of Trying Neaira: The True Story of a Courtesan's Scandalous Life in Ancient Greece
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Fast-paced Memoir about Compulsivity and Self Discovery, Nov 7 2005
By Joel McIntosh - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Hungry Years (Hardcover)
Leith's book is a powerful read for anyone who has grappled with compulsive behavior. His memoir reads like a stream-of-conscious odyssey of a bright guy struggling to master his relationship to external desires for food, alcohol, drugs, and women. In the end, he discovers that his goal of mastery may have been misguided, and that his compulsivity may be more about his need for emotional calm than external pleasure. Leith's book is funny, intelligent, and, in the end, optimistic. While the book tends to get bogged down when the author spends too much time explaining the ins and outs of the Atkins diet and the theory that supports it, it is a generally fast moving read that engages the reader.
|
|
|