The Italian Secretary: A Further Adventure of Sherlock Holmes: Amazon.ca: Caleb Carr: Books

Product Description

From Publishers Weekly

Writing a Sherlock Holmes tale is, for popular writers, equivalent to playing Hamlet for male actors: a challenge that few refuse and many regret. Bestselling author Carr (The Angel of Darkness, etc.) acquits himself with honor, though not high honors, in this short novel that pits Holmes, Watson and Mycroft Holmes against conspirators at Queen Victoria's Royal Palace of Holyrood in Edinburgh, Scotland. When the men are killed at Holyrood in a fashion similar to the slaying centuries before of David Rizzio, an Italian confidant of Mary, Queen of Scots, Mycroft, who is Victoria's head of intelligence, calls upon his brother and Watson to help solve the mystery. Are the killings the work of Scottish nationalists? Or perhaps the sign of a restless ghost? From the latter question, and the novel's primary setting of the dank castle, emanates a well-drawn atmosphere of gloom that makes this story a nice companion to The Hound of the Baskervilles. Holmes fans and scholars should be pleased with this novel, which generally hews to "the Canon" (unlike, say, Nicholas Meyer's Seven-Per-Cent Solution) and reflects a deep knowledge and understanding of Holmesiana, but the primary base for this novel will be, of course, Carr fans, who won't be quite as thrilled—for while the novel captivates, it matches neither of Carr's previous megasellers in plot invention or depth of character. Still, this should hit bestsellers lists, though not in a major way. (May 10).
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. --This text refers to the Hardcover edition.

From Booklist

When Conan Doyle had Sherlock Holmes take the plunge into Reichenbach Falls, little did he know that eventually he would be compelled to resurrect Holmes--or, more amazingly, that countless other writers would also revive the Baker Street sleuth. Carr, author of The Alienist (1994), is the latest to try his hand at constructing a new Holmes adventure. Where contemporary authors go wrong is in trying to replicate Conan Doyle's style and in trying to duplicate the verbal sparring between Holmes and Watson. Carr fails on both those scores, but aside from that (and that's a big aside), the novel has a number of appealing features for readers who enjoy Carr and don't mind secondhand Holmes. Chief among these is its setting, Holyrood House, the royal palace in Edinburgh. The gloomy aura of Edinburgh, particularly the Gothic pile of Holyrood, is a perfect foil for a Victorian mystery. The plot centers on two deaths during the reconstruction of parts of the palace: the suspicious accident that befell the chief architect of the refurbishing and the murder of his foreman, both near the site where Mary Queen of Scots' trusted advisor, David Rizzio, was stabbed to death three centuries before. Very improbably, the scientific-minded Holmes suggests that Rizzio himself may be avenging his death through the new murders. Great setting, intriguing history, but clumsy evocation of the inimitable Holmes. Connie Fletcher
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved --This text refers to the Hardcover edition.

See all Product Description

Suggested Tags from Similar Products

(What's this?)

Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product)

western(1)

Customer Reviews

2 Reviews

5 star:		(0)
4 star:		(0)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

Average Customer Review

2.5 out of 5 stars (2 customer reviews)

Share your thoughts with other customers:

Create your own review

Most helpful customer reviews

3 of 3 people found the following review helpful

3.0 out of 5 stars Not Carr's strongest work, Jan 4 2006

By

Travis Weir (Ottawa, Ontario, Canada) - See all my reviews
(REAL NAME)

This review is from: Italian Secretary (Hardcover)

I have to admit, Caleb Car is one of my favourite authors, without a doubt. His work in The Alienist is amazing and unparalled in the genre of historical mysteries.
Carr does an excellent job of sticking to a late 1800s style of prose, much like what the original Doyle stories are written in. But, where Carr falls short is the depth of the plot. Its thin, and although there are the makings of a good ghost story within it, any reader can guess who the culprit is well before the climax.

I do however still have faith in Carr, and I hope he continues with another installmant of "The Further Adventures of Sherlock Holmes".

Help other customers find the most helpful reviews

Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

Report abuse

2.0 out of 5 stars Hugely disappointing, Aug 10 2006

By

Rob Nicol (Toronto, Ontario, Canada) - See all my reviews

This review is from: Italian Secretary (Paperback)

I read and enjoyed Carr's The Alienist and The Angel of Darkness, so I had been looking forward to reading this for some time. Unfortunately, it was quite disappointing. Boring plot, weak character development and a terrible ending. The outstanding character development, pacing and plotline that you find in The Alienist just aren't present.

Help other customers find the most helpful reviews

Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

Report abuse

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See both customer reviews...

Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com ^(beta)

Amazon.com: 3.0 out of 5 stars (103 customer reviews)

93 of 100 people found the following review helpful

4.0 out of 5 stars Any Truth is Better Than Indefinite Doubt, April 19 2005

By Leonard Fleisig "Len" - Published on Amazon.com

Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)

This review is from: The Italian Secretary: A Further Adventure of Sherlock Holmes (Hardcover)

So said Sherlock Holmes in The Yellow Face. Any indefinite doubt I had about Caleb Carr's ability to craft a credible and very enjoyable Sherlock Holmes adventure was dispelled in the first few pages.

I have read and enjoyed Carr's earlier fiction, The Alienist and The Angel of Darkness. One of the hallmarks of both books was Carr's ability to create a seemingly auhentic picture of life in 19th-century New York. He also created a wonderful pair of characters in Dr. Lazlo Kreizler and his trusted comrade John Schuyler Moore. However, Carr faced two hurdles in writing the Italian Secretary. He had to recreate the atmosphere of Victorian-era Scotland, a region he was probably not as intimately familiar with as New York City. Further, while Kreizler and Moore sprung solely from Carr's imagination, here Carr had to find authentic voices for the esteemed Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson, whose characterization by Arthur Conan Doyle must be fixed firmly in the imagination of anyone who has ever read the original Holmes tales. That is no easy task.

I have read virtually all of Conan Doyle's work but admit that I cannot claim as much expertise as devoted Baker Street Irregulars or other followers of Holmes. However, this amateur thinks Carr has done a terrific job replicating their original voices. It sound like Holmes and Watson to me.

The plot line is set out in detail in the product description and I won't go on at length about the plot or discuss any of the many twists and turns along the way. I did like the way Carr threw Sherlock's brother Mycroft into the story. Carr does an excellent job describing the petty sibling rivalries that must affect even the most accomplished of brothers.

Carr does a very good job of revealing bits and pieces of the mystery every few pages. The story is fast-paced and the many twists and turns in the story left me continually wanting to read just one more chapter before I put the book down for the evening. For me, this is the mark of good adventure tale.

In an afterword. Jon Lellenberg, the U.S. representative of the estate of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, suggests that Carr write a new story in which Holmes and Watson meet up with Carr's Kreizler and Moore. I do hope Carr takes a stab at this.

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle wrote in "The Man With the Twisted Lip" that "a trusty comrade is always of use; and a chronicler still more so." Carr has done a marvelous job in chronicling the further adventures of Sherlock Holmes. This is a book that will be enjoyed by fans of both Carr and Conan-Doyle as well as by readers who simply like a fast-paced, well written yarn.

48 of 53 people found the following review helpful

4.0 out of 5 stars To Scotland, Watson!!!, April 23 2005

By Dash Manchette - Published on Amazon.com

This review is from: The Italian Secretary: A Further Adventure of Sherlock Holmes (Hardcover)

Being familiar both with the Sherlock Holmes tales and the fiction of Caleb Carr, I approached this book with interest. The result was a worthwhile read as Carr sends Holmes and Watson off to investigate murder and intrigue in Scotland.

As a Caleb Carr novel, THE ITALIAN SECRETARY is quite good. The book is exciting and the plot holds the reader's interest. Carr greatly expands the character of Mycroft Holmes, Sherlock's brother, who has a special though vaguely defined relationship with the queen. Mycroft calls upon his brother and Watson to investigate murders that may call the queen's safety into question.

As a Sherlock Holmes story, the result is a bit weaker. Carr captures the relationship between Holmes and Watson very well. His portrayal of their individual personalities is fairly good though just slightly off. This does not disrupt the story, however, and merely serves to remind us that Carr is not a clone of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

Carr's weak spot is that his portrayal of Holmes' logic is not as tight as one might have hoped. Although some clues are presented to the reader, they are tied together far more loosely than in the original stories. Although Doyle himself would sometimes have Holmes make inferential leaps, those times stood out starkly as the exceptions to the rule. Indeed, one major plot twist is presented by Holmes stating what he had earlier observed even though no clue whatsoever had been presented to the reader. This makes THE ITALIAN SECRETARY read more like a crime novel than a detective novel.

Another point to note is the subtle supernatural aspect that Carr employs in the book. Although he tries to gloss this over in the final chapter, it nonetheless feels artificial in a Sherlock Holmes tale.

I realize that many Sherlock Holmes fans read books such as this simply to look for fault and errors and I therefore make the above criticisms hesitantly. This is a Caleb Carr book and should be judged as such. And, as stated above, it reads quite well from that perspective. I include such criticisms for the purists who would read the book from a different perspective. For everyone else, sit back and enjoy.

9 of 9 people found the following review helpful

4.0 out of 5 stars The Game's Afoot!, April 1 2007

By LoriDee - Published on Amazon.com

This review is from: The Italian Secretary: A Further Adventure of Sherlock Holmes (Mass Market Paperback)

I enjoyed Caleb Carr's The Italian Secretary. Any Holmes fan big or small can appreciate the effort put forth by Mr. Carr in this enjoyable novel penned as a "further adventure of Sherlock Holmes" The story takes place in the ghost infested Holyroodhouse which was the castle of the ill fated Mary Queen of Scots. A cryptic message from Mycroft Holmes protrayed here in a rather unpleasant light as the bigger less able brother of Sherlock sends Dr. Watson and Mr Holmes hurtling towards Edninburgh.

What Carr has done well is imitate the chatty descriptiveness of Dr. Watson's writing with a fairly well done plot that is mildly suspenseful. It is filled with historical data and interesting history of the surroundings. What is less impressive to me is the portrayal of Holmes who doesn't really get to shine with his detective skills and deductions. He is rather in the background to Watson's verbose prose and thoughts. All in all though, it is a good work with an enjoyable plot with a little supernatural drama thorwn in for good measure. Well done!

› Go to Amazon.com to see all 103 reviews 3.0 out of 5 stars