Most helpful positive review
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
A Good Tolkien Dictionary
on January 24, 2003
I bought this book before checking it out much. Now that I've got it I've been looking on the internet, and have heard, to my dismay, that this book is incorrect and out-of-date.
Therefore, I no longer use it for a guide on Elvish, which was what I was (and still am) looking for. Instead, I use the dictionary to increase my somewhat small vocabulary of words, in Elvish and Tolkien's other languages.
The conlusion: I would recommend buying this book with another book, like An Introduction to Elvish (that's not the full name, just type in "An Introduction to Elvish" in the Amazon.com search field and you'll get it)...