From Library Journal
While the title promises a study of the complex relationship between an older and younger gay man, it is clear after the first few chapters that the book is more about Quinn and his gay identity than his friendship with mentor Joe Riddick. The book could be titled The Mentee. The author draws detailed parallels between himself and Riddick, both "recovering Baptists" with complementary Southern family backgrounds, but there is little mentoring. Instead, Quinn treads the well-worn path of gay autobiography and fiction, featuring life in the hedonistic 1970s and 1980s, as he chronicles his experiences with licit and illicit drugs, his attempts at an artistic career, his manic-depressive episodes, and, above all, his sexual exploits. While Riddick never emerges as a flesh-and-blood personality, Quinn does, and an unappealing one at that. This book feels like a half-baked autobiographical novel puffed up with pop psychological and sociological background to make it relevant as nonfiction. Not recommended.
-Richard Violette, Special Libs. Cataloging, Inc., Victoria, BC Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
"Jay Quinn's exploration of the mentoring process within the gay community -of being taken under a wing, of being taught by the more mature, of learning from someone trusted -shines with honest grace. He's taken the very personal and amplified it into an exemplar for a community which has a lengthy, noble tradition of the older guiding the younger; but it's a tradition not much honored in our writing or in our public lives. This memoir, candid and Humane, intimate and witty, is an eloquent recognition of what one generation can teach another." --
Richard Labonte, General Manager, A Different Light Bookstores, San Francisco, California"When you read Jay Quinn's THE MENTOR, it's as if you're reading a book written by two different men, complimentary and sympatico. One is a Southern storyteller, the kind that has made the South famous for its rich literary history -you can hear Quinn spinning a yarn up on the front porch, offering any number of juicy scandalous stories, confiding a couple of secrets, keeping a couple more to himself. And there's another writer, a thoughtful scholar who knows how to tell a tale on the page as well as the porch, who can look at his own life with enough wisdom to convey to others what he has learned. And that is what THE MENTOR is all about -teaching and telling each other effortlessly, the reader and writer at once protege and professor." --
Brian Bouldrey, Writer and editor, San Francisco, California