Most helpful customer reviews
4.0 out of 5 stars
Suspenseful Dark Stories, Served in Short Form, Mar 31 2011
This review is from: The Museum of Dr. Moses: Tales of Mystery and Suspense (Paperback)
Joyce Carol Oates is one of America's best, and most unclassifiable, writers - she's considered a "literary" author, but writes across genres at will; I've read her short stories in mystery magazines, best-of-the-year science fiction, fantasy and horror volumes, and everyplace in-between. This 2007 volume, "The Museum of Dr Moses," contains 8 short stories and 2 novellas published between 1998 and 2007, in magazines ranging from F&SF to Ellery Queen to Ploughshares to McSweeney's to Playboy, with a couple published in original anthologies edited by the likes of Otto Penzler and Dennis Etchison (separately, of course!). She is probably the only writer in the world who can take a subject that not only doesn't appeal to me, but actually repulses me (here, the world of boxing) and write a novella so intrinsically compelling that I will savour the 60 pages that it takes her to tell the story ("The Man Who Fought Roland LaStarza"); yet she can tell an equally compelling story in 3 pages ("Stripping") that is, in its implications, more repulsive than anything else in this volume. She is, in short, a gem, especially in short form; I like her novels too, but she really excels in the shorter format. My favourites here include "Valentine, July Heat Wave" (which I admit I'd read before), "The Hunter," "Feral," and the title story. If you want a master class in how to inculcate deeply rooted psychological truth in short form writing, you can do no better than to study Joyce Carol Oates. She's amazing. And yeah, obviously, recommended, though you might need a strong stomach for some of her tales!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Chilling tales of evil in the ordinary, Dec 28 2007
By Lynn Harnett - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Museum of Dr. Moses: Tales of Mystery and Suspense (Hardcover)
Oates' stories don't include a single ghost or supernatural event. Instead these 10 macabre tales focus on the happenstance of evil colliding with ordinary life. Many of the stories carry a sense of inevitability. The opening story homes in on the bullying personality of a beefy runner who likes to startle the weaker runners in his path. You know how it's going to end and can only watch, with a certain uncomfortable satisfaction. Some, like "Valentine" - a monologue from a spurned man to his lover - have a Poe-like feel, lucid but unhinged. From the first word the outcome is certain, but the reader is riveted all the same. Others imagine the psychological effects of a very specific event - the change in a long-awaited child after a near-death accident; or the strange, halting absorption of understanding that Daddy is a serial killer. These are stories to be read singly, not in a gulp. They are visceral, gruesome and unsparing of the darker aspects of human nature; also beautifully crafted and compelling.
9 of 12 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
Oates Does It Again! (Unfortunately...), Sep 27 2007
By Notnadia - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Museum of Dr. Moses: Tales of Mystery and Suspense (Hardcover)
It's often said that no American writer has ever had a greater capacity to re-invent herself than Joyce Carol Oates. The trouble is, not every new literary incarnation of this great writer is an improvement on the old. When she released what might be regarded as her first true collection of macabre stories with 1994's Haunted: Tales of the Grotesque, it was a bold move for this woman whose primary reputation rested on the strength of her non-genre writings, and most received that book with generous praise. The trouble is, little did we know then that she would return to mine this vein again and again, and with each visitation find less there. The Museum Of Doctor Moses serves to gives us some very disturbing short stories. As a whole it contains one passably good story, the title one, an Oatesean tale that is both believable and shocking enough to merit some praise, and its presents some lesser pieces that I've already halfway put out of my mind. The remainder of the collection falls somewhere beneath the quality of the story of the disturbed and disturbing Doctor Moses, and at times well below it. "Hi! Howya Doin!" was as direct as A+B=C, and could easily have been constructed by a gifted seventh-grader. "Suicide Watch" had a "lifted from the headlines" feel to it, as did much of Oates' far superior 1991 collection Heat, and while not a terrible story, was decidedly unworthy of the talents Oates has long proven she owns. "Stripping" the worst story in this anthology was frankly a waste of paper, ink, and time on both the reader and writer's behalf. The revenge-themed "Valentine, July Heat Wave" was the story that more than any others in Doctor Moses has the tone of classic Joyce Carol Oates, but even it was not particularly memorable. Which leaves a half-dozen other stories I'll decline to comment on here. None of what remained to be read was all that bad or all that good, either, but all in all were disappointments. Perhaps I expect too much from Joyce Carol Oates. She has spent half a century crafting an impressive body of literature sure to be read and studied for many generations. At her time of life she has certainly earned the luxury of writing what she wishes. I only wish that she would "reincarnate" into a form that would lead on to something more worthwhile than most of what she's published thus far in this decade, the tens. Read at your own discretion but don't be surprised if you come away a little disappointed.
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Macabre Deluxe, Sep 10 2007
By Jon Linden - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Museum of Dr. Moses: Tales of Mystery and Suspense (Hardcover)
"The Museum Of Dr. Moses" is perhaps one of Joyce's greatest efforts in the milieu of the macabre. Unlike many of her previous books and stories on the theme, this book actually discusses situations that are much more day to day occurring and much easier to empathize with than are some of her most gruesome stories of the past. In many ways, this technique brings the world of the macabre in coincidence with the world of daily life. In her story "Hi! Howya Doin!" she describes a jogger who in his physically fit and nonchalant manner becomes an irritant to others. It is easy to imagine this irritation, and how some others might react to it. In fact, it is interesting for the reader to imagine, that even the somewhat unexpected and macabre end is something they can actually empathize doing. Other stories are even more detailed and more graphic in illustrating the macabre. Yet each of them are tied enough to regular daily life, that it can be imagined by the reader. It can even be imagined that the reader could be in that position. For example, in her story, "Valentine, July Heat Wave" the story involves a couple that have recently separated and a final meeting prior to the inevitable divorce. Yet this meeting is not like any other in the past. Once again, Joyce's style of portrayal is such that the reader can imagine being in such a similar situation, without that much of a stretch. Only an assumption that their spouse is a little crazed. That in fact probably covers about 96% of marriages in America. Using this new style, Joyce allows the reader to come close to the macabre experience through her articulation. The book is recommended for all readers interested in tales of the grotesque and macabre. It is also highly recommended for JCO readers in general as it is a new stylistic metamorphosis on the theme for the author.
|
|
|