Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
Bold and ProvocativeDec 26 2009
Dr. Robert H. Moore, coauthor of "School for Soliders: West Point and the Profession of Arms" and "Spreading the Risks"
- Published on Amazon.com
"The New Enlightenment" calls for "a new way of thinking about spirituality, civilization, and cultural progress." Its author, Grady Means, has crafted a remarkable narrative filled with perceptive and surprising observations.
Given the tone and argumentation of this original commentary, some readers may be puzzled to discover the author is a prominent Republican who has served in the White House, a formerly active Catholic layman, and a successful businessman who has managed billion-dollar global management consulting practices and authored books on international business. Yet, he is now the author of a provocative and incisive critique of serious deficiencies in Catholicism and other major world religions.
One of his primary theses is that these belief systems in their "doctrines, rituals, and codes" are "following the same path -- a path that cannot represent God's intent." He argues that they "tend to separate and rank human spirits rather than bringing them together under the rubric of love."
His concern is that "doctrinal religions are, by their very nature, opposed to values" such as "individual initiative, human liberty, fairness to the less fortunate, human equality" and "when applied in a fundamental form in the political arena can be corrosive to human peace and liberty."
Highly recommended for those who are open to exploring new roads on their spiritual journey.
This is a brilliant bookApril 8 2012
- Published on Amazon.com
This book is truly brilliant. It speaks for the silent majority rather than the extremes that have hijacked religious debate. Every religion and all decent people believe we should move forward together with reasonableness, love and compassion for all that Grady suggests. It is inspiring, and reminds us of the ideals that led America to become a beacon of hope around the world.
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
Step away from the dogma...March 4 2010
Matthew J. Faulkner
- Published on Amazon.com
Grady is asking us to step away from the dogma, embrace our spirituality and implement a New Enlightenment, rooted in the original Enlightenment that formed the initial colonies of what is now the United States of America.
I was brought up in a protestant household, attended Sunday school, sang and toured in a choir, played guitar and composed religious songs and assisted in running group events for children.
I watched as lives were destroyed (alcoholism, depression) around arguments about service formats, modern or traditional hymns, guitar vs. pipe organ and the hierarchy implied by being "born again". I began to think about the schism between faith and religion. I stopped attending church.
I can only agree with the conclusion that all doctrinal religion is corrosive, and the text articulated what I had "sensed" over the many years I have considered the man made nature of religion. Grady offers powerful tenets to renew our spirituality, the framework neatly dodging creation of a new dogma by asking us to connect and follow our spirit.
I have noticed that politics and religion have become intertwined. The move away from God and the Spirit has left a vacuum for many people, whether they admit it or not. As someone once observed, people keep saying "God is dead" (meaning religion), but addressing the reasons why God needed to be there in the first place are in short supply. "The New Enlightenment" covers this subject well.
I observe that politics has become like religion - unreasonable beliefs that are maintained by ignorance and enforced by like minded communities. The polarization of the US populace along feuding party lines is a testament to that. I see discrimination along party lines with exclusion by membership on both sides. Business organizations are microcosms of this - "process/ ideological politics" being used to crush/ force change through polarization (rather than party politics). Even removing religious right/ intellectual dictatorship left - politics have become a doctrinal religious experience for many.
Religion, culture, politics and gender are the foundations of bigotry - it is just the share of mind that changes.
Grady is articulating a case for change using doctrinal religion as an example. But the core issue as stated is true - people seek convenience, guidance and community - a spiritual life is way too difficult for many - there is no easy guidebook to self awareness, love of others or seeing the world through the eyes of others. If I am comfortable with a course of action and there are enough around me to affirm my position, I must be "safe".
Unreasonable beliefs and ignorance are corrosive, magnifying each other exponentially - religion is a manifestation, as is politics. Religion and Politics may be too genetically intertwined through the very nature of ourselves to ever be separated. However, the observation that religion is a big stick wielded politically is correct.
The start of the book reminded me of Coulombs' law, concerning the attraction of masses in free space. My electrostatics lecturer stated that everything can be derived from this equation. I have thought about this my entire adult life and have not been able to prove him completely crazy. Spiritual people should be attracted in free space by the weak forces; the issue is making the space free once again.
I am a new American. I was attracted to this country by its optimism, creativity and open business environment. At the conclusion of the citizenship ceremony, I was encouraged to engage in political discussions, enabling me to vote from an informed perspective, fully participating and contributing to our democratic government. Grady is asking that we renew our citizenship vows, embrace American Enlightenment and renew it with love and the spirit.
I just wish every Christian, Jew, and Muslim would read this book, and reflect a bit on what their "religions" are asking them to do and to believe, and why -- -even when it often goes against all "reasonable" thought or intuition. (And is often self-rightous and exclusive, i.e. "believe what we believe or you will not be saved, or you are not a good person".) The author, a self acknowledged "catholic" and successful business man, is a thoughtful and insightful individual who brings up fascinating "food for thought" regarding the how's and why's of what motivates people towards dogmatic religions, and what keeps them there. Although the second section on"Theonomics" has a lot of charts, and might sound too "businessy" to some people, it is dead on, and absolutely a brilliant analysis of how bureaucracies operate (which any organized religion is) and as an ex- catholic myself, it finally made me understand exactly how situations like the pedophile problem got so out of control and was so obscured by "the organization" (and why woman have been so excluded from the church)....and how muslins are willing and encouraged to do "honor killings"....and how "religions" often distort scripture or readings, and use them to control and keep people "in the flock" to support the institution ----rather than helping us each to tap into our own spirit voice. Etc etc.... Fascinatiing analysis.
There are also some thought provoking sections on the ten commandments, and so many of the things I have wondered and thought about in terms of life, death, salvation, eternity....and when it all began.... This is a book that I think anyone who has the slightest doubts or questions about their own spirituality vs. what the religion they are part of is telling them -----or is ready to think hard about these questions - will find much food for thought and reflection...As the author states, since we live now in a period of time when a few fundamentalists can blow up a good part of the world with their non negotiable stances ---it is time to step back and look at religions a little more closely, and understand what we each are subscribing too ----it would be odd to end the world over religious stances and dogma, rather than listening to our own humanity and spirit...This book helps us think about these issues.