1.0 out of 5 stars
doesn't date well, May 16 2009
This review is from: The Official Story (La historia oficial) (DVD)
Given that Argentina's Dirty War where thousands of citizens were "disappeared" is a fantastic topic to cover, I was let down by this movie. This thing moves way too slow to have any impact in 2009 when I saw it. The problem is you can see exactly where the story is going. No surprises at all really as the script telegraphs everything.
The only powerful scene I connected with was the mothers of the disappeared in central Buenos Aires.
Sooner have seen a documentary detailing more on exactly what the Dirty War was all about rather than eluding to it through the character Roberto.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Norma as Alicia, Oct 30 2002
This actress is phenomenal in this role. She IS Alicia and her portrayal of coming to terms with Argentina's dirty war secrets is the most compelling acting I've seen in my life. She is simply remarkable and the film's power and emotion center on her flawless portrayal.
Some heart-wrenching moments:
When she gently unfolds her baby's cloth diaper, long saved in a box of momentos from her infancy, or when she snuggles up to little Gaby, holding tight to her child, the woman's agony becomes so real that you forget that you're watching a movie and your heart feels the pain of her situation.
I've seen this movie at least 10 times and I find myself still tearing up when Norma performs Alicia so masterfully.
An interesting symbol I've noticed in the film:
The opening and closing of doors.
----Alicia watching the doors swing back and forth while witnessing the birth of a child in the hospital
----Alicia seeing a door at Roberto's office suddenly close, to hide a criminal act in progress
----Roberto closing the door on her fingers, as if to keep her from passing through the door
----Alicia's departure, the silence leading up to the heavy close of the door, as we see her profile finally pass through.
(These are the examples that come to mind. I'm sure there are more)
In the context of Argentine history in the mid 1980's, the country itself was passing through a door to democracy.
(Un pasito para allí, que miedo que me da...) The music is a perfect thematic instrument in the film as well.
What a complex and aesthetic film this is!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Story Of Us, Sep 5 2001
As and argentinian citizen, I think this is the one of the most representative film about us, ever made. The screenplay shows in a very close way, the dark years of our history, when democracy was just a dream. Norma Aleandro and Hector Alteiro are simply perfect in their roles and the music of Atilio Stampone is oustanding. The first (and by the moment, the only) Oscar for Best Foreing Language Film, to Argentina. I'm really proud that people around the world could appreciate this magnificent film.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No