The Optimist's Daughter [Hardcover]

 

 

Create your own review

Like love, grief is ultimately something that we must all go through alone. There can be people who help, but our emotional journeys are ours alone.

And that is the heart of "The Optimist's Daughter," a dark, quiet little novel set in the mid-20th century South. Eudora Welty explores a difficult, emotionally wringing topic -- one woman losing the last loved one she had, and the struggle to come to terms with the many people she's lost.

Elderly but healthy Judge McKelva goes in for an eye operation, but seems strangely lethargic afterwards. His daughter Laurel -- who has been away for several years -- is concerned as her father continues to decline, especially since his flaky second wife Fay is treating him badly, and even has to be physically restrained by a nurse. Then the judge dies.

And Laurel finds herself in her old family home, trying to deal with Fay, her weird family, and the many well-meaning-but-dense friends that McKelva had over the years. But when the house is empty and she is alone, Laurel looks back on her life -- her all-too-brief marriage to a loving man, her mother's horrible death, and her father's remarriage -- and learns how to feel again.

Few books that I've read really handle the subject of grief -- usually people hug, cry, and get over it except for a few pages every now and then, when there is a mention of the Dearly Departed.

But not many authors can really get to the wrenching, lonely core of grief and loss, and how it can set us free, or lock our emotions and throw away the key. And that is basically what "The Optimist's Daughter" is all about -- McKelva's illness and death are a prelude to Laurel's soul-searching, and the exploration of how she handles her grief.

Welty wraps the slow, gradual storyline (which takes only a few days) in warm, colourful prose ("Sienna-bright leaves and thorns like spurts of matchflame had pierced through..."). She does have a tendency to let the dialogue from various people ramble, but often that rambling makes some very sharp points about loss, such as how the well-meaning often tell white lies about the dead, or ignore their dying wishes.

Laurel is kind of a nonentity for the first half of the book -- she's all locked up in herself, and we don't know much about her. But then Welty paints the devastating pain and guilt that she's been feeling, and shows how you have to let go of the past in order to live the future. Quite a contrast to the childish, putrescent Fay, whose rallying cry is always "What about ME?" and who accuses her dying husband of ruining her birthday.

"The Optimist's Daughter" is only optimistic as it ends -- up until then, it's a beautifully painful look at love, loss, and grief. A magnificent story, if a rather uncomfortable one.

Welty's Pulitzer Prize-winning novel is largely told in the third person through the observations of its heroine, Laurel McKelva Hand, the daughter of a prominent and wealthy smalltown Mississippi judge who comes to New Orleans to help her father who must see a doctor for an eye affliction. On hand is the judge's second wife, the silly and vulgar Fay, whom Laurel and the doctor basically ignore. When the father unexpectedly dies, Laurel (who is older than Fay) must return to the smalltown with her stepmother for his funeral.

The reasons for Welty's popularity with THE NEW YORKER editorial board are much in evidence: the story is told subtly and in small pieces, and accrues a remarkable level of hospital and genteel smalltown detail as it proceeds. Its measured rhythms are the best thing this novel has going for it. Unfortunately, it seems to proceed too much along the lines of a contest between discreet Southern gentility and refinement (embodied in the quiet and grieiving Laurel) and no-'count Southern lower-class vulgarity (championed by Fay and her obnoxious Texas relatives). Although Laurel comes to realize why her father's late-life optimism explains why he married Fay, Welty doesn't really allow Fay any sort of appeal to the reader at all, and so you finish the novel thinking how much *nicer* everything would have been had the judge never married her. (At least Tennessee Williams allowed Stanley Kowalski animal magnetism.) The novel seems too much on the side of delicacy , especially given that Welty's own fine feelings are so manifest in her method of telling of the story--though paradoxically some overobvious symbols (a carved boat, a breadboard, the judge's degenerating eye) weigh things down a bit much. The work is most interesting at the end, when Laurel must confront some truths about her real mother's final illness which complicate the overly schematic family alignments in some welcome ways.

Laurel is a quiet character; though she is the center of the book, she rarely speaks. Welty captures Laurel's greif at the death of her father with all of the accompanying conflicting emotions.

Laurel's character was developed largely from the tangible details about the way she conducted herself with her father, mother, Fay, and the people from her town, as well as descriptions of her memories. She was a complete character through her interactions with the other characters and her memories which were brought on through her interaction with her surroundings. And though Fay seemed a little bit one-dimensional, she was by no means evil--there are stupid people in the world :)

Contrary to some of the other reviewers I felt like the simplicity and grace of Welty's prose deserved the Pulitzer Prize.

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 29 customer reviews on Amazon.ca

 

4.0 out of 5 stars Quietly Epiphanic
If you have long wondered what the fuss about Eudora Welty is all about, read THE OPTIMIST'S DAUGHTER, the 1973 Pulitzer Prize-winner for fiction. Read more

Published on April 9 2003 by C. Ebeling

4.0 out of 5 stars The optimists Daughter
I thought this book was well written but missing some elements. When the book first started out it was very confusing. Read more

Published on Oct 28 2002

4.0 out of 5 stars Especially meaningful to people of a "certain age."
Winner of the Pulitzer Prize in 1973, this moving study of memory and the progression of generations is still vibrant and relevant thirty years later. Read more

Published on Aug 28 2002 by Mary Whipple

5.0 out of 5 stars The finest in Southern melancholy
I'm not a big fan of Southern fiction in general, but this short novel is definitely a brilliant achievement. Read more

Published on May 24 2002 by David A. Bede

5.0 out of 5 stars A Work Designed To Please The Mature Mind
At the time of her death, Eudora Welty of Mississippi was generally considered America's greatest living author. Read more

Published on May 14 2002 by Gary F. Taylor

4.0 out of 5 stars A haunting novella that lingers in the reader's mind
This book is the conclusion of Welty's thematic trilogy of Southern family life: while "Delta Wedding" concerns a family gathering for a marriage ceremony and "Losing Battles"... Read more

Published on May 6 2002 by D. Cloyce Smith

2.0 out of 5 stars Much ado about_______?
I've always wanted to read a Welty book and I picked this one. Unfortunately, because now, I don't think I'll try another. Read more

Published on Mar 20 2002 by S. Grgas

5.0 out of 5 stars Perspective on confluence
I believe Eudora Welty chose the story she tells in "The Optimist's Daughter" to present her own point of view (attitude) regarding the inevitable results of the... Read more

Published on Mar 2 2002 by M. Roussin

4.0 out of 5 stars An interesting read
This story is basically about a woman named Laurel who makes some realizations about her family and herself. Read more

Published on Nov 22 2001 by Robert Ortiz

1.0 out of 5 stars How did this win the Pulitzer?
Thankfully, this was a novella or I would have never finished it. The story is pointless. The protagonist is a weak, spineless woman who allows herself to be abused by her... Read more

Published on Aug 23 2001 by T. zisis

Search Customer Reviews
Only search this product's reviews

› See all 29 customer reviews on Amazon.ca

Search Listmania!