9 of 9 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
familiar story set to music, Oct 7 2006
This review is from: The Perfect Circle (Paperback)
This is not a quick read, it's not one for the subway or your lunch break, but it is one for delving and imagining and running off to Italy with.
It opens with a passage in the second person, never easy to read at the best of times but hang in there, it tells the unnamed narrator's story in a nutshell, a very sad, lonely nutshell, and sets the premise for the rest of the story: to tell the story with names changed, to create some distance perhaps, or to handle the emotions and learn from them. It has an autobiographical feel but that's simply the author's skill.
The rest of the novel tells the story as fiction, with Marianne meeting and falling in love with Marco, going back to Montreal and then borrowing money to fly to Italy again as soon as Marco invites her. He lives in a small village by a lake where two tourists drown every year, where everyone fishes. He owns the terrace house he grew up in but doesn't live there, leaving it empty while he eats and sleeps at his mother's house next door. The entire street is inhabited by his family, with aunts all around.
Marianne is not exactly welcomed. They like to talk about her, but not to her. She has the same conversation over and over again: "Are you German?" "No, I'm Canadian" "Oh, Marco's girlfriend." She wrestles with his mother for the right to cook for him, but can't please either of them. While Marco, a plumber, drives off early in the morning to do his thing, Marianne spends lonely days drawing or walking by the lake, until eventually she takes a horribly underpaid waitressing job at a busy restuarant.
This is one of those books that has to be read more than once to fully grasp, understand and appreciate every word. The writing style is like poetry and philosophy, not always easy to follow, revealing so much in precise movements. This is one of those fine examples of writing as art, or music, and you cannot help but be right there with Marianne as she experiences something so familiar yet so bitter. And it is a familiar story, sadly so, yet the ending justifies the whole ordeal as Marianne grows and faces the truth. Marco is a sad character, content with his life, not willing to change, unreachable in the most important ways. He too is familiar, as is his mother, never mind that they are Italian - it just shows how similiar we all can be.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Perfectly Obsessed With Reading Pascale, Aug 16 2008
This review is from: The Perfect Circle (Paperback)
"If you watch my hand move through space, you will
realize that it's trying to find you.
Already it's been searching for a long time, even longer
perhaps.
Touching you, it would say: I'm looking for you.
it would say: I haven't stopped loving you.
And it would say: I had to break out your perfect circle."
That's why I am so obsessed reading Pascale. I don't have any problem with dust when I am reading but I can't stop having allergy like symptoms when I was reading you. Well written. Comes from the bottom of the one's heart.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Shining, Brilliant (in parts), Mar 13 2007
This review is from: The Perfect Circle (Paperback)
At times there is writing here to take your breath away. The first part is a gem of prose. You read that and immediately know why it was shortlisted for the Giller Prize. When people talk of freewriting, they mean this -- it spins across and through the human mind and soul -- it alights and moves on, building toward a true moving experience. Unfortunately it doesn't ring as solidly through the entire book. The plot is the main problem, she keeps rushing back to Canada back to Europe back to Canada back to Europe and we get a bit dizzy wondering why the author felt such a need to do this. But as the childhood poem says, when she was good she was very very good.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No