The Shellcoder's Handbook: Discovering and Exploiting Security Holes [Paperback]

Get some new editors!

What amazes me, and the reason of me not giving five stars to the book, is the enormous amount of errors in the book (no one else has talked about this on previous reviews). These go from forgetting to include memory allocation routines in some sample code and putting incorrect labels in some diagrams to talking about certain parts of code while actually showing completely different lines of code or talking about different addresses in the explanations from the ones on the sample code and program output that they talk about.

For example, on page 90 the authors wrote:

" Let's take a look at two assembly instructions that correspond to the free() routine finding the previous chunk

0x42073ff8 <_int_free+136>: mov 0xfffffff8 (%edx),%eax
0x42073ffb <_int_free+139>: sub %eax,%esi

In the first instruction (mov 0x8 (%esi), %edx), %edx is 0x80499b8, the address of..."

The instruction being referred to at the last sentence should be "mov 0xfffffff8 (%edx),%eax". "mov 0x8 (%esi), %edx" appears many lines below this paragraph, in another code sample, and it is completely unrelated to the explanation given there.

Of course, people familiar with these topics who also have a deep knowledge of the required programming languages and architectures will catch these flaws easily. The problem is that there are so many of them that it gets annoying at some point and you end asking yourself why do the editorial reviewers didn't do their job properly.

Also, I bought this book almost as soon as it went out for sale, yet as of this date (may 2004), the only material found in the web page of the book is the source code to most of the examples. Definitely much less compared to all the material that the authors promised in the book to be there (so don't expect to find more than this).

It is an excellent reference book though, and if you take the time to read the book thoroughly and make notes to fix the errors in the book you will find that even this activity is rewarding. Some might even argue that the authors put the errors there on purpose to keep script kiddies away from this knowledge, but I don't think that would be OK with a book like this which has created so much expectation. Hopefully the next edition will have all this fixed.

Parts 1 and 2 are a great introduction of OS internal, system calls, memory management, and in-depth analysis of security bug exploitation; thus making them relevant for part 3: "Vulnerability Discovery". Part 3 goes into great depth on how discover security bugs. No so often do we have the brightest minds in the art of software vulnerability discovery, penetration testing, or "ethical hacking" joining forces. The variety of ways to discover security bugs is what we need to learn in order to ship secure software or to successfully secure existing software applications. Great Job!