1.0 out of 5 stars
What a pile of ship!, Jan 9 2003
I have to say, Kevin Spacey does a remarkable job playing Quoyle, the depressed loser. And when I say loser, I don't mean some Jason Biggs character who has a hidden personality waiting to be awakened. I'm talking about the kind of loser with no redeeming characteristics whatsoever. If you don't believe me, just watch the scene where he ineptly tries to court Julianne Moore's character by putting his head on her thigh and crying. I would feel pity for him and his childlike innocence, but he never seems to escape his role as the guy who can't do anything right. Sure, he eventually manages to earn the respect of his coworkers, but he works for a LOCAL newspaper for crying out loud! It's not like he's going to be nominated for the pulitzer prize any time soon. By the end of the film (if your head hasn't already exploded out of sheer frustration with Kevin Spacey's character) even the most conservative among us will become staunch advocates of euthanasia. And then there's the pirate theme...ugh, I can't even begin to explain how lame it is. Suffice it to say, after being haunted with images of his plundering ancestors, Quoyle decides to hack a boat to pieces along with twenty other drunks, thus confirming that he is the true descendent of a long line of God's mistakes. On the plus side, this movie would make a great public service announcement for kids to stay in school.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Beautiful, Gentle Gem!!, Dec 31 2002
This review is from: The Shipping News (DVD)
Kevin Spacey first snapped my attention as Mel Proffit on the CBS telly series WISEGUY. He played a drug dealing, jet-setting, psycho that went around killing people, freaking out and saying things like "only the toes knows...". Well, if the toes knew, they must have know what a big star Spacey would be in just a few years. He choses films that stretch his untouchable range in the Usual Suspects, the serial killer in 7, the gentle soul claiming to be an alien in the wonderfully moving K-Pax to this gem of a film The Shipping News. This was a gentle, loving, heart-lifting book, so I feared when it came to the screen, all the quirkiness that made it so special might be lost. Instead, it is beautiful realised under Spacey brilliant performance, backed by the ever eternal and radiant Juliana Moore and the utterly marvellous Judy Dench and the solid Pete Postlethwaite, and another super tour de force for the ever solid Scott Glen.
This is a story that touches your heart, the way so many of Hollywood films fail to do, and leave you smiling at the end, and maybe even leaves you missing these near friends you have come to love. It is good to see films like that do so well, just a shame there is not more.
It is brilliantly written, with all the quirkiness you find in a small knit community, the isolation tend to make the locals revel in their bizarre personalities and even sort of wear them like a badge. I have seen this same 'wee tight isle' in Scotland and in Ireland and small towns in the US. Everyone knows everyone - knows the history as far back as it goes. The past is not so distant, where people with the sight is just an everyday occurrence.
Kevin Spacey plays a gentle soul, driven by an overbearing, likely abusive father to believing he was nothing. He felt the world pasted him by until Petal jumped into his car. Petal is typical Hussy type, a lass out for fun and little else. For the first time, Kevin's character feels that he no invisible. Petal gets pregnant, have a baby girl, Bunny, and then precedes to live life just as she always had, with good time guys and honky-tonks. She checks in long enough to upset Spacey, and pat the kid on the head. When the child is about 8, she slips away with child in tow, running away with the latest boyfriend. If that is not upsetting enough, Spacey's father and mother decided life is the pits and check out.
In the midst of finding out Petal died in a car crash with her boyfriend, but sold Bunny to a black-market child adoption ring for six thousand dollars, Spacey's long lost aunt,(Dench) turns up to steal her brothers ashes. (Won't reveal what she does with them!! She encourages Spacey to take his daughter and move back to New Foundland to where his family comes from. Once there his daughter shows tendencies of 'the sight' but it is taken in stride.
Scott Glen owns the local paper and hired Spacey to write the shipping news. He fears failure in this, since Petal just reinforced his worthlessness instilled by his father. However, instead, he comes into his own. He also begins a tentative romance with Moore, with his daughter taking to her son, who suffered brain damage during birth.
Spacey faces his demons and learns to heal, as Dench confronts her own secrets and shames, and loves to move on.
The scenery is gorgeous, raining and foggy ( sorry I am a Scot and love a bit of the wet and fog makes me want to walk in it forever. This captures the moodiness, though the snow in May does make one shudder!)
This is just one beautiful movie. You cannot say anything higher.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Powerful..., April 17 2003
By A Customer
This review is from: The Shipping News (DVD)
Many messages, but the most important is LIFE GOES ON. Only fools live in the past. Be sad, grieve, pick up the pieces, move on.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No