5.0 out of 5 stars
A very good Holt gothic, one of her best, Mar 11 2011
This is one of my favourite Holt novels. It is a classic, atmospheric gothic novel, but it also focuses on a heroine who is taking a peek at her own foibles, and actively taking a part in the hand she was dealt by destiny.
Caroline Verlaine is a young widow. She put her musical career on the shelf to be married to Pietro Verlaine an extremely gifted pianist, only to be left to her own devices when he died prematurely. She visits her sister at Lovat Stacy's newly arranged archaelogical digs and is intrigued by the great house, and her second hand impressions of the people living there. Later when Caroline is back in London, she hears of her sister's disappearance and can't quite believe in the explanations that are given. The digs were not popular, and Caroline's sister, Roma as a single woman is an unusual figure as the head of such a project. When the opportunity presents itself, Caroline decides to go to Lovat Stacy without revealing she is Roma's sister to investigate the disappearance.
In this novel, the plot centers on family relations and a rift that happened when an accident took the life of the cherished first son of the Stacy's. It makes the plot doubly interesting because it is rooted in long festered emotions. At the same time, those meanderings bring about a reflection of Caroline on her mourning of her late husband, and what the relationship meant. It is very well written that at the end, two avenues for Caroline's future have been explored and her choice ends up making perfect sense with a conclusion that seems almost inevitable because it is rooted in Caroline's personality. It is the author's clever work in characterisation that makes this happen.
As always the setting imbues the atmosphere of the story and the relative proximity to a boat quagmire and Roman ruins gives the less active parts of the story a sort of mournful tone. Cleverly the same setting plays a role in the plot and this reinforces the gothic feel of the book. It is exploited as well as could be expected in the genre. The secondary characters provide the author with ways to show us the workings of the main characters' minds, and also kind of combine into the setting. This works so well that the denouement of the story does come as a shock even though it was foreshadowed consistently.
A very good read for those who like the genre. And maybe also for those who are not fans, but who like a novel that does play with a bit of contemplative pacing and focuses on inner feelings, less than actual physical attraction.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No