Most helpful customer reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Celtic Fantasy Suggesting Scotland IS The Western Isle, May 5 2011
This review is from: The Silver Bough (Paperback)
I can't believe I missed "The Silver Bough," by Lisa Tuttle, when it first was published in 2006; she's one of my favourite authors and she writes novels far too infrequently for me (this is, I think, her fourth full-length novel since "Windhaven," co-written with George R.R. Martin, appeared in the mid-1970s). But I'm absolutely thrilled to have found it, however belatedly. "The Silver Bough" is set in Appleton, a small seaside town on a peninsula in the west of Scotland, described by folklore as having once been an island, until in the mid-1600s, it somehow got attached to a tip of the British Isles. Incomers appeared after that, bringing with them the craft of apple-growing, as the climate and soil turn out to be perfect for that fruit, and eventually one arbourer creates the Appleton Fairest, the best apple in all the Isles. But times changed, and the apples failed, and by the time our story opens, Appleton is almost a ghost town, struggling to stay alive in a modern world that has no need for it. Enter several new incomers, three American women from different times of life, including young Ashley whose grandmother was born and raised in, and precipitously left, Appleton in 1950; Kathleen, a transplanted librarian given the job of grounding and eventually modernizing the local library, a magnificent structure built by a local architect some hundred years earlier; and Nell, who has been living at and restoring the Orchard for the past several years, after the sudden death of her husband in a sailing accident. Nell has cut off contact with other humans, mostly, but has filled her days with restoring the old house and planting its gardens, including a walled garden that had previously been home to an apple orchard and which now, thanks to Nell, is an apple orchard once again. She has found an old ailing tree and grafted it, and finds that the Appleton Fairest may truly be alive again. But the Appleton Fairest is far more than a mere apple, however tasty; its fate is tied to the fate of the town, and vice versa, and the three incoming women are the key to determining that fate....None of the above gives even the slightest sense of just how magical this story is, and how wonderful. Tuttle writes in a very clear prose - I am never struck by a particularly "poetic" sentence or turn of phrase, but instead find that after reading a paragraph or a page or a chapter, I have a whole world in my mind that wasn't there before, and all of it is poetic and stunning. Anybody who loves fantasy (including dark fantasy; this is more gentle than some of her work, but there's some scary times here too), or is interested in mythology or in the Celtic worlds, or just loves good, clear writing, is well advised to search this book out. And then go on to discover all of Lisa Tuttle's other work too; this woman is a treasure, to be sure. Very highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
A good fantasy read..., April 16 2006
By Samatha Smith - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Silver Bough (Hardcover)
I have been getting into more fantasy like Gaimen's Neverwhere and thought I should try this book. I got it ahead of time in a reviewer copy format from my work. I thought the setting was great - a lonely peninsula in Scotland where time has nearly stopped. Tuttle writes pretty well and keeps you guessing so you want to know what is going to happen next. I only have one criticism and that is Tuttle wrote about fantasy creatures and places but you never really visit it them in the novel. She touches around the edges of the fantasy realm and leaves you hanging a little bit.
7 of 9 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Compelling fantasy, Aug 9 2006
By N. Bonner - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Silver Bough (Hardcover)
Lisa Tuttle is a great storyteller. I almost missed my train stop, I was so involved in this book. The book centers on three women, all American, Ashley, Kathleen and Nell. They happen to be in the Scottish village of Appleton just in time for an earthquake to cause a landslide that cuts the peninsula off from the mainland. The earthquake turns things around in Appleton, once famous for its orchards and cider. But in 1950, Ashely's grandmother did not fullfil her role as the Apple Queen, and by the time Ashley arrives, there are no more apple trees at all. Tuttle brings the magic in gradually through a stranger called Ronan, who turns out to be her grandmother's former fiance--presumed jilted when granny disappeared from the village. Ronan touches the lives of Ashley and Nell as magical creatures descend on the village that becomes totally cut off from the rest of the world. In the end, he ends what seems like a curse on Appleton and restores Nell's life. The story itself was fresh and original. But I only gave it four stars because Tuttle's language was often crude and flat, which tended to bring me out of the story and make me realize I was just reading a book. It also bothered me that she neatly wrapped up the lives of Kathleen and Nell, but left Ashley, the first character we meet and the catalyst for much of what happens, in limbo. She never really describes Nell, and I envisioned her as an elderly widow until the very end of the book, when it becomes clear she is young and beautiful. A physical description somewhere along the line would have helped. Still, I enjoyed this book and would recommend it.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Amazing book!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!, Jun 17 2006
A Kid's Review - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Silver Bough (Hardcover)
The book starts off definetly with two feet firmly planted in the real world. Ashley is finding her roots and going back to Appleton, Scotland where her granny came from. However, a landslide isolates the dying town. Soon, people are seeing mermaids, kelpies, and ghosts. It might put the town back on the map again, but first someone must eat the golden apple... A mixture of modern and myth, superbly blended together into a gripping plot.
|
|
|