3.0 out of 5 stars
Somewhat disappointing, April 26 2004
By A Customer
This who-dun-it kept me engrossed about half way through, but disappointed me at the end because the suspect was too predictable. A weak point of the plot: how could the thief know if and when Claire Reynier would leave her truck with the valuable books unattended (a dumb thing to do for such an intelligent heroine). Claire is an interesting character, but the repetitive descriptions of her daily routines get tiresome. Who cares if she lets the cat out every time she comes home from work, or eats another frozen pasta dinner (it's a wonder she can stay healthy on a diet like that!) And one gets bogged down by all those lengthy paragraphs describing traffic and road conditions every time she sets out to drive somewhere. On the positive side, the plot is refreshingly unusual and the descriptions of New Mexico and its culture are vivid.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
What a great book for book lovers!, Feb 2 2004
Author Judith Van Gieson took time out from her mystery series starring Neil Hamel, to create a second series. This is the first book in what I believe is a superior series to Hamel.
The book's a gift to booklovers (much like John Dunning's work), in that, as a rare-books librarian at a University campus, heroine Claire takes us into the world of collectors, readers, what makes value, and just the love of all things "bookish". She's an interesting heroine, with grown children, newly divorced from a marriage that makes you wonder (why did she stay?)and a new job in the often cutthroat world of academia.
A wealthy mentor has died, leaving his books collection to the University where Claire is employed. It's a feather in her cap, but she also finds herself needing to agree to be the executor of his estate. His odd family and his ranch, in a rancher vs. naturalist part of New Mexico have you saying silently to her..."What, are you nuts?"
From both the donation and the need to be the executor come the mysteries. I must say, I thought the culprit in each would be different, but I was proven wrong. The mystery line is gentle, probably a good way to introduce a librarian into the world of crime solving.
The real star in this book, however, is Gieson's imagery and depth of feeling for the New Mexico landscape. Both the raw power and beauty of the area are on display for all to see and enjoy. She's really given the reader something solid here, as I found myself homesick, and wishing I had a Southwestern desert vacation planned. I'm looking forward to the rest of the series.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Now, this was a good book.., Mar 29 2001
By A Customer
As a lover of the Southwest, I found Stolen Blue was very satisfying. I found myself underlining all sorts of places, books, etc. mentioned in the text to follow up. The "atmosphere" was terrific..
The negative was that the "mystery" aspects of the book were transparent. You KNEW the books would be stolen from her car, you KNEW the "History of the Blue" would be the important stolen book (the title alone gave it away!)so there weren't so many "surprises" that mysteries often have. And the eventual "killer" seemed somewhat arbitrary.
Still, the the writing drew you in, the atmosphere held you there, and the "mystery" pulled you through! The quasi-intellectual aspects were also a plus.
More!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No