From the Hardcover edition.
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
Of course, as in all great romantic epics, the two are destined to meet again. Tilman loses his leg in the war and experiences joyful belonging with an exuberant Italian immigrant family in industrial Hamilton, Ontario, before finally venturing home. Klara remains a spinster in her small town, sewing and working on and off for years on the figure of an abbess carved from wood. The novel culminates in the building of a huge stone monument to Canada's war dead in Vimy, France. Klara and Tilman are both compelled to visit the site of this insanely ambitious artistic obsession of real-life Canadian sculptor Walter Allward; both find that they have a personal struggle to overcome the past and learn to express love. Urquhart grasps her characters from outside and inside as precious few authors manage to do. She is, in her own way, a sculptor who carves a radiant and enduring tale from the elegant material of raw language. --Nigel Hunt --This text refers to the Hardcover edition.
Urquhart very convincingly conveys the futility of war and depicts how young men go off to war for all the wrong reasons - hoping to fly an airplane, for instance.
Urquhart's strenth as a writer is her ability to paint beautiful pictures with words - her description is unsurpassed. She uses symbols quite well, although at times not subtly enough. In this book, the bird imagery was a little overdone when it came to Tilman. However, she portrays the grand sweep of history while, at the same time, evoking the mood and atmosphere of a small Ontario town.
The weakness in this book is the characterization - for the most part, these characters are one-dimensional and just not believable as real people. For one thing, they are too nice. It is hard to believe that Tilman, on his own since the age of 6 and losing a leg in the war, would not be more bitterly scarred than he is.
Read this book for the beauty of the images and for the history lesson. If you're looking for great characters, you won't find them here. The flaw with this book is that the characters are just not deep enough to adequately deal with the grand themes of obsession and redemption.
|