3.0 out of 5 stars
Not Baum's finest, but a rare read for his fans, Dec 16 2009
By Sunny Sewing Honeybee - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: The Twinkle Tales (Paperback)
_The Twinkle Tales_ is a first-time collection of several mini chapter "books" by L. Frank Baum, all starring a little girl by the name of Twinkle, and her friend Chubbins.
The books are as follows:
In _Prairie Dog Town_, Twinkle and Chubbins are miniaturized and visit a prairie dog town and speak to its residents.
_Bandit Jim Crow_ features an injured crow that Twinkle is given as a pet. He quickly escapes and decides to live with other birds, to their chagrin--considering the fact that he likes to eat them!
In the tale _Mr. Woodchuck_, Twinkle visits a woodchuck family and learns the truth about the cruelty of animal traps.
Twinkle captures _Prince Mud-Turtle_, who can speak once a week. During a moment of speech, he reveals that he's actually a fairy prince who needs her help. Here, finally, is a twinkling of Baum's humor and magic, hardly seen in any of these stories.
_Twinkle's Enchantment_ tells of Twinkle walking past a hidden line into a magical world. There is some word play used, including poking fun at such statements as "the walls have ears" and "pop goes the weasel."
In _Sugar-Loaf Mountain_, Chubbins again features into the story, when he and Twinkle discover a hidden door in a mountain, which leads to a city where everything is made entirely of different types of sugars.
_Policeman Bluejay_ is the final story and the longest. Both children get lost, and a tuxix turns them into birds. The moral message here is mostly about hunting.
Twinkle and Chubbins do not really have the same type of magical adventures as fellow Baum creation Dorothy. In fact, they visit the natural world, and most of their adventures are educational and at times dark, explaining how animals are killed or otherwise mistreated by people. While the animals can talk and have anthropomorphised features and habitats, they are not humorous or eccentric in the way Oz creatures are. Overall, this is not Baum's finest; it comes across as preachy and not nearly as innovative as the Oz stories. Perhaps the main problem, though, is that the tales are too short to develop much of a storyline. Yet even the longest has little of one itself. They often end abruptly, without any real conclusion or conventional storyline arc.
This is, nevertheless, a volume for Baum fans, since these specific tales are a rare find, especially all in one volume. If nothing else, reading this book gave me an even great appreciation for the originality of the Oz books.