(NOTE: The low rating is for this particular 2011 Blu-Ray edition, not the movie itself.)
I'm enough of a fan of the X movie to have bought it no less than THREE times over the years -- Laserdisc, DVD, and now on Blu-Ray. I consider it one of the absolutely greatest masterpieces of the rockumentary genre. It went beyond making me fall totally in love with the band to also encompassing cultural meaning and history far wider and deeper than the scope of the band itself.
So I have to ask, WHAT THE HELL WERE THEY THINKING to crop the top/bottom off the movie to make it faux "widescreen"?!? For anyone really familiar with the movie, this totally butchered the frame composition. Furthermore, IMO, "Cinemascope" really doesn't fit the rest of the punk aesthetic of the film as well as the 3x4 aspect ratio did.
Yeesh, the movie's short enough, couldn't they have included two versions if they had to have a chopped version for whatever reason?
To compound the problem, the Amazon product description improperly cites the aspect ratio as 1.33:1. (Maybe that's how the release was originally planned/announced?) The outer case doesn't bear any warning that "this film has been modified from its original format to fill a widescreen TV" either. If this sort of thing matters to you, buyer beware.
Fortunately I still have my old Image DVD. It looks like that earlier DVD edition is even still available through Amazon. I'd personally recommend that fans get THAT version instead before those copies disappear, even with its arguably muddier transfer and standard-def resolution.
I'll have to watch it further to see if the bonus materials make the Blu-Ray worth keeping. Otherwise, my copy is quickly headed for the second-hand market. :-(