3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
The one and only "best of" album to date, Feb 25 2004
This review is from: The Very Best of (Audio CD)
This is the very first compilation that covers the band's entire career, including works from both Warner Brothers (1967-72), Grateful Dead Records (1973-75) and Arista (1977-89). This 17 track CD is to be considered a "greatest hit" rather than a "best of" collection, which would have contained more live material. This album contains some of their most famous songs, like "Truckin'", "Touch of grey", "Sugar magnolia", "Eyes of the world", "Friend of the devil", "Estimated prophet", "U.S. blues" and "Uncle John's band". Grateful Dead was never a single's band, so this CD doesn't pay a fair duty to the band, but it's perfect as a starting point. This is definitely the place to start. And if you're satisfied with one Grateful Dead CD only, this should probably be the one.
But this CD shouldn't be you only Grateful Dead CD in your collection. Grateful Dead was, by all means, a LIVE BAND, and on this CD you'll find only one live version ("One more Saturday night"). So, if you should happen to like this CD, check out some of their live recordings too. There are a whole bunch of live albums available, so it's often hard to decide which one to buy and which one to avoid. Well, let me help you. You can't go wrong if you buy either of the following three albums: "Ladies and gentlemen..." consists of live recordings from five shows at the closing of Fillmore East, April 1971. "Stepping out...England '72" is a compilation of highlights from their UK gigs on their famous European tour in April and May 1972. "The closing of Winterland" covers the entire New Year's show at Winterland 1978/79. All three CDs show Grateful Dead on top of their career, and it will sure give you an experience of a lifetime!
Back to the CD: The period from 1971-72 is, for some reason, not represented in this "very best of" collection. The majority of the songs (7 of 17) are from 1970, including five from their best studio album "American beauty". The rest of the songs are mostly from 1973 to 1978. "The golden road" (1967) represents their early years while "Touch of grey" and "Hell in a bucket" are songs from their commercial break through, as late as 1987.
One single CD with the very best of Grateful Dead will always cause problems. Since everyone has their own favourites, you can't put all the best songs on one CD. It's just impossible. But some songs are definitely missing. OK, I can understand why a 23 minutes "Dark star" wasn't included, but what about songs like "Scarlet begonias" and "Playing in the band"? They are way more essential than "Fire on the mountain" or "Hell in a bucket"! Songs like "China-cat sunflower", "The other one" and "Me and my uncle" could easily have made it to this compilation too. Personally, I would have liked to see "Going down the road feelin' bad" on this CD.
But don't misunderstand me, this is a great record, and it should be found in every music lover's CD collection. It's a highly recommended CD!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Beats "Skeletons" by a long shot., Jun 28 2004
This review is from: The Very Best of (Audio CD)
This is the Dead's best greatest hits album. A good place to start for new fans, but I wish it had more live tracks...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great Sound Quality/Haphazard Collection, Feb 22 2004
This review is from: The Very Best of (Audio CD)
For a band with a duration of nearly thirty years, the Grateful Dead haven't been anthologized nearly as much as people might assume. Their San Francisco peers, the Steve Miller Band and the Jefferson Airplane have produced so many anthologies that it has underminded the integrity of their original releases. The Dead, on the other hand, have had a much longer career trajectory and this is the first single cd anthology that covers their entire career span...well, sort of. This anthology is overly reliant on their Twin Towers studio albums, "Workingman's Dead" and "American Beauty". I have probably heard "Truckin'" over 10,000 times in my life and sitting though that song is the sonic equivalent of fingernails on a chalk board. "Uncle John's Band" seems to never wear thin and thousands of listenings later, it remains the most unique and powerful statement of the Dead's collective metaphysics.
Among the missing and unaccounted for are; "Dark Star," "Jack Straw," "Black Peter," "Stella Blue," "Brokedown Palace," "Playing in the Band," "Wharf Rat," and "Terrapin Station." The biggest puzzler is what happened to "Aoxomoxoa" and "Anthem To Sun?" The tribal elders of the Deadhead nation are certain to frown upon any collection that omits "St. Stephen", "China Cat Sunflower", "The Other One" or "Alligator." These two albums broke open more musicial space than any other Dead albums, and are the cornerstones of the Haight Ashbury psychedelic renissance.
Now that the Grateful Dead has remastered all of the 22 official albums, the hardcore Deadheads will probably want to recollect all of the orginal releases, because there is a significant improvement on the sound of the remastered editions. The track separation has dramtically improved the listenability of even some of their most ragged sounding efforts. Each time I've listened to the remastered editions of these tunes I've picked up on musical subtleties that were unmasked by the remixing of the analog masters, using the highly developed digital technology that we now call "state of the art". So for me, I will be buying (for the third time) all the 22 Grateful Dead offical releases that have been remastered. It will take some time however, because there seems to be no end to releases from Dick LaVala's archieves or ones from "The Vault" that keep on coming. Until I can afford to rebuy all of the remastered offical releases, this haphazard collection of Dead tunes sounds fantastic.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No