3.0 out of 5 stars
I think the weakest book in this trilogy., April 30 2004
This was an enjoyable book in some respects, but I found that it wasn't nearly as gripping as the two previous books in this Boston gaslight series. For one thing, there wasn't much mystery here. We knew almost right away who the killer was, and it was just a matter of Addington running around trying to find him. Also, we never saw a resolution to the sexual tension between Caroline and Dr. MacKenzie. Knowing this was the last book in the series, that surprised me a bit. In fact the book finished with lots of unresolved issues. The book is about the Victorians fascination with seances and contacting people "from the otherside". Caroline attends a seance to try to contact her dead mother, and while the lights were down, the man sitting beside her (in fact holding her hand) is killed. Addington did not want Caroline to attend any seances, so he was perturbed when he found out that she had and that the unthinkable happened while she was there. Then he finds a link from that death to the man who was in prison for fraud, and who Addington believed was responsible for the death of his father. The man is a confidence artist, and he bilked many people of a lot money, including his and Caroline's father. The book becomes a chase to get this man after that, and I didn't find that it was that suspenseful.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2.0 out of 5 stars
i am not really sure about this book, Oct 8 2003
i discovered this book while browsing at my favourite book store. i was desperate to find something, anything to read. being
a huge fan of anne perry's and having read all her books when i
saw this one i grabbed it. after reading it i am not sure i enjoyed it or if i would buy another one. i found the characters
unlikable. each of the main three were so bound up in their
own prejudices and snobbery that it was all i could not do
not to throw the book across the room. the 'charming caroline'
who most reviewers found a delight.i found silly and vapid especially for a 36 year old woman,spinister of not. her brother was just
a charmless snob who seemed to think his birthright gave him the
right to judge everyone else wanting. dr. mackenzie was the only one who came close to be interesting. the characters were
three dimensional. i guess i am spoiled because anne perry does
such a superb job of creating likeable although flawed people
who have depth of character and personality. also i must say
that not knowing the city of boston(i am very familiar with london)a lot of the historical detail was wasted on me. the
mystery was run of the mill. i think i will buy another one
of series and if it is similar i shall go back to rereading anne perry's early works.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Superb third in the series, I loved it!, Aug 27 2003
By A Customer
As usual Cynthia Peale did not disappoint me! And I am so glad. I enjoyed The White Crow as much if not more than the first and second books in the series. Her characterizations are excellent (and not just the main characters!), the plot is entertaining and well-planned, and the way she captures old Boston at the turn of the century is nothing short of brilliant. I feel that I am there learning about what Boston was really like. To find this atmosphere of a Boston past in a modern-day book is amazing. I am eagerly awaiting a fourth in the Beacon Hill series. Please!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No