I enjoyed all the parts of this novel, and even the illustrations and extras were worth spending time . Although comedic, it still has a good storyline. When you can feel that this part of England could really exist, and willingly suspend dis-belief in the world of books being real and separate from this dimension, then you have a successful story and an engrossing series.
I'm hoping that more will be forthcoming from Mr. Fforde, both in this series and in the other worlds he has carefully constructed.
Was this review helpful to you?
Attempting to give even a partial summary of any Jasper Fforde novel is kind of like trying to drain the ocean with a teaspoon, so I won't even take a stab at describing "The Woman Who Died A Lot," the seventh, and latest, in his wonderful Thursday Next series. I *will* note that it involves an older, damaged Thursday, along with a bunch of sort-of replicants; the evil and dominating Goliath Corporation and its favourite henchman Jack Schitt; the strange and mysterious, and thus far unproven-to-exist, realm of the Dark Reading Matter, access to which is much enhanced by the unfocused "buffers" of dodo birds; Jenny, who does or does not exist; Aornis the wicked; the continuing fall-out from the dismantling of the Chronos Guard, making Time and the Future of some of our heroes somewhat relative; and librarians, lots and lots of librarians. Who are, of course, the true heroes of the story and the Saviours of the Universe.... No, one cannot pick up any old entry in Jasper Fforde's Thursday Next series, one must start from the very beginning ("The Eyre Affair," and I am tremendously envious of anyone who still has the absolute astonishment of that book before them; I wish I could read it for the first time over and over and over and over and.... but I'm turning dodo here, better get rid of that mindworm now!). Just read it; read everything Jasper Fforde has ever written. You will be a better, happier, stronger person, and Goliath Corporation will have one less unsuspecting victim to suck dry. Did I mention it's highly recommended?
Was this review helpful to you?
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
60 of 64 people found the following review helpful
When worldbuilding crushes plotOct. 9 2012
Daniel L Edelen
- Published on Amazon.com
Books tell stories. That's what they do. Good books tell good stories. Great books not only tell great stories, but they transport readers to someplace out of the reader's experience and immerse them in a different world.
No one in modern fiction has built a more intriguing, fully realized, and humorous world than the alternate Earth of Jasper Fforde found in his Thursday Next series. What's amazing about his accomplishment is that he has technically built more than one world in the series; his Bookworld adds yet another layer to Thursday's quirky reality. Now, in his latest release, _The Woman Who Died a Lot_, Fforde has added the world of Dark Reading Matter, which the end notes of this book state will be the focus of the next Next novel.
Yet in reading _The Woman Who Died a Lot_ a major issue with the direction of the Next series becomes clear. As good as Fforde's worldbuilding is, it is overwhelming his narrative. At some point, all the goofy "Nextian physics" and time travel and alt history and parallel realities and parallel subrealities and alt religion start to crowd out something critical to good books: a decent story.
What made the Thursday Next series so much fun was not just the odd world author Fforde thrust his heroine into, but the fact he built that world around good plots. But as the last few books have proven, wrapping a paper-thin plotline around a world doesn't work as well. And sadly, _The Woman Who Died a Lot_ doesn't have much of a story.
Most fans of the series may not miss the fact that it takes a third of the book before a plot begins to emerge. They will love all the goofiness, puns, knowing references, and so on that are the hallmark of this series. That's all well and good, but without a solid story, who cares?
Fforde also betrays himself by hammering his already fragile plot into something like flakes of gold leaf. The novel contains MANY chapters, each a break from the chapter before it, each a subunit of the book, and each subsequently feeling disconnected from the whole. In short, the book doesn't so much flow as it jerks from event to event.
Notice this review's lack of overview of the plot for this book. Problem is, a summary of a couple sentences goes far too far in betraying the entirety of the plotline. Because there isn't much of one--and what there is resembles three or four short story ideas cobbled together, none of which is capable on its own of sustaining a full-length novel. And that's a huge problem.
To make matters worse, the events that kick the plotline forward are so convoluted it makes this reader wonder if all the Nextian physics are interfering with, rather than boosting, the storyline. The wacky world of Thursday Next and her family feels like an intruder, like some annoying person tapping you on the shoulder every couple sentences while yelling, "Notice me!" It all becomes too self-aware, as if Fforde has lost control of the world he so carefully crafted in earlier books.
As a longtime reader of Fforde's books, I wonder if he needs to burn down some of the world he has built and start over. Perhaps the Dark Reading Matter world will be his stab at this. But then, it's just another world to add into the existing ones that already overwhelm the Next novels.
For this series, it seems to me that Fforde neeeds to go back to the main and the plain. We need plot over puns. Labor to make the story interesting and the world of Thursday Next will enhance the plot. But when worldbuilding takes center stage, plot suffers. And we readers don't want to suffer through Thursday angst without a decent story driving it.
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful
The real Thursday Next is backOct. 13 2012
- Published on Amazon.com
It's 2004 in the alternate Britain of the now semiretired literary detective Thursday Next, and she's getting older--54--but as her husband Landon tells her, when weird comes knocking gray hairs count more than the lost physical prowess she's mourning. Weird, ironic, and mind-bendingly wonderful is of course exactly what you get in a Thursday Next novel. I've loved just about all of Jasper Fforde's books, but the Thursday Next series is my favorite by far and even in that group this new one is stellar.
The last book featured the fictional version of Thursday from Book World, but here we are back with the original Thursday. When the book opens, Thursday is still struggling with the mind worm planted by one of her enemies which makes her believe she has a daughter who doesn't exist. Tuesday and Friday, her actual daughter and son, are moving towards adulthood. Tuesday alternates between high school high jinx and cutting edge invention--she's trying to create a giant shield capable of warding off pillars of fire the newly invigorated and angry universal deity is bent on smiting Earth with. Friday is at loose ends. He had been destined to become the most renowned leader of the ChronoGuard, a sort of time traveling police force, and he'd even met his time traveling older self in earlier books, but when it was discovered that time travel hadn't actually been invented in the future the ChronoGuard was disbanded.
Thursday herself is in a career slump, or thinks she is. She is hoping to be put in charge of the re-formed SpecOps Literary Detective Division, but that job is given to a younger woman and Thursday is forced to accept a head librarian job. Adding insult to injury, the mega-corporation Goliath has engineered a series of synthetic Thursdays who combine superhuman capabilities with the ability to download the real Thursday memories.
Meanwhile, a deadly asteroid may or may not be on a collision course with Earth, and something strange is going on in the newly discovered but very little understood field of Dark Reading Matter. Intriguingly, it looks like Dark Reading Matter may be the setting for the next Thursday Next Novel. Can't wait!
27 of 34 people found the following review helpful
Fforde in ffine fform! (no spoilers!)Aug. 21 2012
- Published on Amazon.com
Most of those reading these reviews will already be familiar with Jasper Fforde and the Thursday Next series. If you are not one of them, Stop, Do Not Pass GO, and start with the first Thursday Next novel, "The Eyre Affair". You might not give it 5 stars, but know that the series gets better with each novel, at least for the first four, where it hits a high point for me with "Something Rotten".
So, if you know Fforde and the Next series, why are you here? Certainly, not to get the plot spoiled. I won't spoil it. Perhaps, it's because, like me, you found the previous novel "One Of Our Thursdays Is Missing" to be a bit of a let down. I also didn't enjoy "Shades of Grey" much (because I couldn't develop sympathy for any of the characters). But, I enjoyed the other Next novels so much that I spent almost as much on postage as the book itself to have it shipped from the UK.
So, the question is, "Has Fford lost it?" I'm delighted to report that, if he did, he's found it again!
Maybe if OOOTIM wasn't such a letdown I'd likely have given TWWDAL four stars ("Something Rotten" is still my favorite), but having Fforde back in fine form is by itself worth the five stars.
It is tempting to talk about a subplot or some other detail, but you're already a fan. All you want to know is whether the book might be a disappointment. It isn't!
Here's something of no consequence other than to show that TWWDAL is classic Fforde. Describing a temporal gradient...
"...I [Thursday] walked back up the gradient. I turned back to Friday and asked if he was okay.
"He said he was but I could see that his mouth wasn't moving when he spoke. I was talking to him as he was now, but [i]seeing[/i] him as he would be in about thirty seconds. Conversely, he was hearing what I said now, but seeing me as I had been half a minute ago."
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful
Time slows down for Thursday NextOct. 19 2012
Author Bill Peschel
- Published on Amazon.com
It is a truth universally acknowledged that a world-weary hero preparing for the climactic battle must say something like, "I'm too old for this."
Except in the case of Thursday Next, because the heroine of Jasper Fforde's mind-bending alternative-world series has encountered so much weirdness that it's doubtful that a boundary exists that she hasn't already smashed through.
Battling the undead? Check. Befriending reconstructed Neanderthals? Been there. Meeting Miss Haversham? She trained under her. The end of her life? Bought the nightgown. The end of the universe? Not only reached it, but circled around to the beginning. Banal English television? Got the DVD.
If you haven't paged through her first six books, then you should drop this review and get them. If you like Douglas Adams, "Alice in Wonderland"- like logic, classic literature, books in general, and the kind of literate mind-bending weirdness that English writers carry off with such aplomb, it's a guaranteed pleasure that you'll love Thursday Next.
But if you're still with me, then I have an opinion you might not want to hear: "The Woman Who Died a Lot" is . . . all right.
"The Woman Who Died a Lot" opens in media res with enormous changes afoot. The SpecOps Network that Next worked for as a Literary Detective had been abolished and is undergoing reformation. It's been discovered that time travel doesn't exist, so the ChronoGuard that monitored the timestream had been disbanded. Seriously injured at the end of the last book, Next hobbles about on a cane and needs pain patches to get through her day, and she's still beset with a mindworm that makes her believe she has a daughter, Jenny.
See, "The Woman Who Died A Lot" is a lot like the clones that pop up in the book. They look the same as the real thing, they function just as well, even better in some ways. But they don't last long, because they don't have a digestive system, hence their brand name, Day Players.
Same thing with the book. Part of the problem is that Fforde set up a couple of major events in the opening chapters ─ the destruction of downtown Swindon by God on Friday and the mindworm plot ─ then has to wait until the end of the book to set them off. In between, there's not a whole hell of a lot that Thursday can do about them, so she has to deal with other issues. She tries to get a shrink to classify her at the right level of insanity to win a job leading the Literary Detectives; deal with her nemesis, Goliath Industries, which controls society; and figure out the cause of a plague of Thursday clones seemingly intent on replacing her.
All in all, a pleasurable read, with occasional laugh-out-loud moments; librarians will especially love their role in Fforde's world. Despite my complaints, I breezed through this book even when I had more important things to do. So maybe it's me. Maybe I'm irritated because Fforde has two other series whose books I've eagerly awaiting for years ─ the comic Nursery Crimes with its mix of noir and children's lit, and the brilliant Shades of Grey trilogy with its light-based mysteries just begging to be unwrapped ─ and I'm put off by another Thursday Next (or a book in his fourth series, "The Last Dragonslayer," which left me cold). Maybe I'm too old for this.
But there you have it. Not Fforde's best book, but ─ well, I won't say worst, because that implies that there is a worst Thursday Next book, and that's not true. Like Terry Pratchett's Discworld books, a decent Next is still better than a lot of author's best efforts.
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful
The Reader Who Was Entertained A LotOct. 12 2012
- Published on Amazon.com
I haven't enjoyed a Jasper Fforde book this much since Something Rotten (Thursday Next Novels), the fourth book in the series.
The Woman Who Died A Lot, the seventh book in the series, has a lot in common with Something Rotten, mainly that we're back to the real world after a major detour through book world in the previous volume. Normally I would lament the loss of BookWorld, but after the confusing outing that was One of Our Thursdays Is Missing: A Thursday Next Novel, I welcomed the reprieve.
The real-world setting gives this novel a little more direction, not that Fforde would ever allow himself to be constrained by something as flimsy as reality. Thursday still has to deal with the most dangerous job she's ever held (being a librarian), an impending smiting by an angry deity, Goliath clones of herself, and the fall-out from time travel being found impossible back in First Among Sequels (Thursday Next, Book 5).
Fforde does a few things brilliantly here:
1. Thursday is aging. She's older and injured, she hobbles around, has trouble getting up stairs. She's still a bad-ass, but she's just an older, slightly saggier bad-ass. Despite all the ridiculous situations she finds herself in, her character remains grounded in reality.
2. Fforde's writing of memory, memory loss, and its confusing effects is simply genius. Telling a first-person story filled with implanted memories, fake memories, memories some people share and others don't, sudden memory loss, etc., cannot be easy. Fforde pulls it off masterfully. Chapter 36 of this book might just be one of the most brilliant things he has written.
3. The plot is a little ludicrous, but that could just be my distaste for time travel. However, he keeps things rolling along at a good clip and manages this book to feel more like a "literary thriller" than any novel before it. It lives up to its cheesy noir title.
There are also a good many laugh-out-loud moments along the way. A Swindon/Szechuan Fusion restaurant featuring "steak and chips dim sum followed by hot Fanta in a teapot." A righteous man being corrupted by being at "a lap-dancing bar getting plastered and running up gambling debts while eating delicacies made from pandas' ears." Finding the inspiration for Scooby-Doo endings in an obscure work from ancient Greece. Plus some spot-on social satire reminiscent of Terry Pratchett on his A-game.
Tl;dr: This book is delightful. For the first time since the beginning of this new plot arc (beginning with TN5), I'm looking forward to see where Thursday goes Next. (Pun not intended when I first typed it.)