Most helpful customer reviews
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Lyrical, wise and alive -- a sweeping triumph, Aug 19 2002
I was compelled to write this review mostly because of the previous commentary. A lullaby? Hardly. Vivid and stirring, and not at all a textbook tome. As for the supposedly "homogenized" characterizations, I disagree completely. Owen McCarthy, as befitting of a poet, is a poetical character. His reflections on his people and his land are some of the most moving I have read in any novel in ages. The book brings to life not only events -- ugly battles between cannons and pikemen, in all their gore and horror -- but also the tenor of the times, the motivations of all sides in this epic confrontation. And while Flanagan does tend to belabor some of his points and themes in the latter third (which a keener editing eye should have taken care of; this was a debut novel), a reader emerges feeling that every side in this fight had good and bad sides, high motives and base motives. And, having seen firsthand the way that modern wars of revolt and insurrection quickly turn into butchery on all sides, Flanagan's illustration of the conduct and motivations of the warring parties in 1798 Ireland seems as dead-on an explanation of such events as you'll find anywhere. A superb read, astonishing in its breadth and depth and its lyrical skill.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Excellant novel for background on Irish troubles, Dec 2 2005
This review is from: The Year of the French (Paperback)
A lengthy novel illustrating the reasons, attitudes and feelings of many of the classes of people caught up in Wolfe Tone's rebellion and its long term effects. The characters struck me as very real persons in their various thoughts, backgrounds and philosophies on life, war and idealism. This is not a book to be read from cover to cover quickly, it inspires much too much thought. Some reviewers have compared it to 'War and Peace', but I thought that book grander in its scale of action whereas Thomas Flanagan has drawn a very detailed portait of a small campaign and its protagonists. I presume it is reasonably factual with respect to the historical campaign as the book is seemingly dedicated to one of the characters. Recommended for anyone who wants to understand 18th to 20th Century Ireland.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
43 of 48 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Finest historical novel written in English, Dec 3 2000
By Ralph H. Peters - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Year Of The French (Paperback)
Anyone has a right to be suspicious of claims that appear extravagant, but, upon reflection, I genuinely believe this is the finest historical novel written in English, at least in the twentieth century (I suppose we should count "Vanity Fair" and "A Tale of Two Cities" as historicals, but none of poor, old Walter Scott's works compete). Its foreign language competition is limited to a handful of books, From "War and Peace," "The Leopard," and "The Forty Days of Musa Dagh," to "Am Himmel wie auf Erden," "Vor dem Sturm," and "I Promessi Sposi." Thomas Flanagan is simply a brilliant writer--lucid, thoroughly-engaging, controlled and masterful. His prose is flawless. Except for "The Leopard," I know of no historical novel that so richly and convincingly captures the ambience of a bygone world. The weather and the feel of chilled mud, the prejudice of blood, the nuances of the social order and the confusion of military operations, the errors and casual oversights that shape lives, and the interplay of great events and individual tragedies are all so perfectly interwoven and gracefully presented that the reader forgets this is only a novel and enters another reality. Of course, all this will sound like hyperbole to those who have not yet read this book--but once you have read it, you will find it haunts you for a long time. I've given several copies to cherished friends, as I also have done with Penelope Fitzgerald's "The Blue Flower" (which might have been a competitor for "best historical," were it not such a transcendent book that it won't be characterized by any genre). This is a wonderful book--please read it and help keep it in print.
16 of 16 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Sweeping And Poetic, Sep 16 1999
By A Customer - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Year Of The French (Paperback)
The first book in Flanagan's panaromic sweep of Irish history. (see "Tenants of Time" & "The End of the Hunt") Well written with characters the reader cares about set against the historical back drop of Wolfe Tone's failed 1789 rebellion against the English. Compelling, a must read! Once you've read one of Flanagan's books you find yourself wishing he had written more, or started writing earlier.
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
Breathtakingly beautiful telling of a heartbreaking story, Jun 19 2000
By A Customer - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Year Of The French (Paperback)
This is writing at its finest, making the drama of history come alive through characters we relate to and care about. I was swept along from the first paragraph, held captive by beautiful language and vivid detail. As has been said of the Irish, "There's no cause like a lost cause". Writing like this makes one of history's saddest stories live on in the hearts of anyone lucky enough to come across it. I can't recommend this book highly enough.
|
|
|