From Publishers Weekly
Like the recent film
Lost in Translation, Desai's new novel tells of an American adrift in a foreign culture that remains frustratingly inscrutable. Eric is a New England–born graduate student in history at Harvard who follows his scientist girlfriend, Em, on a research trip to Mexico. Once she sets off with her colleagues to conduct field observations, he is left alone and overwhelmed by his own lack of purpose. Remembering that his Cornish grandfather, about whom he knows next to nothing, had worked as a miner in the Sierra Madre in the early part of the 20th century, he determines he will use the trip to find out more about his family's past. Along the way he meets an eccentric, powerful European woman, Doña Vera, who has become a champion of indigenous culture but whose own past is mysterious. The stories of Eric, his grandparents and Doña Vera are interwoven into a short, contemplative narrative. Eric is a passive narrator, clambering his way through the beautiful but beguiling scenery, which is described in florid, dense prose reflecting his sensory overload, in a story that never really gains momentum. While Desai has uncovered a compelling chapter in Mexican history, the novel is a meandering, disappointing journey.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.
From Booklist
Cultural collisions fascinate Desai, a fiction writer of transfixing acuity who has written most often of East Indian immigrants in the U.S and who now, in her fourteenth book, draws on her intimacy with Mexico. Eric, a psychically adrift young American, travels to Mexico after learning, to his surprise, that his father was born there. Open to serendipity and preternaturally receptive to the land and its ghosts, he is drawn to Dona Vera, a gold digger with a secret European past who has set herself up on a remote estate as an expert on the Huichol Indians and their sacred use of peyote. As Eric resurrects the dramatic, even otherworldly story of his Cornish miner grandfather and intrepid grandmother, Desai, with supreme narrative dexterity and poetic distillation, ponders the forces that allowed marauding foreign tycoons to build silver mines in Mexico worked by demoralized Cornish immigrants and brutalized Indians. Infused with history, compassion, and a sense of wonder, Desai's heightened and affecting novel is ravishing in both its specificity and its universality.
Donna SeamanCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.