| ||||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
Would you like to update product info or give feedback on images?
|
Three Jewish sisters, born of the same father struggle for identity (internal, external and religious/cultural), struggle to keep a family together in the only way they know how, whether it be positive or negative, it is the way they have learned from their parental life lessons.
Each sister is unique, within their sameness for identity search and familial bonds. One cannot understand her father, and is a rebel rouser, an antagonistical feminist, who is stuck in time and cannot seem to move forward on her life journey, one is family-oriented, living for her family, one has a career and manages her family at the same time.
Through Pogrebin's subtleties, we see that the three different personalities, in the end, have similar substance, and are more alike than they think or would like to admit.
I enjoyed reading the Jewish journeys each of them took, their treks through time, backward and forward, to learn forgiveness, to learn commitment to family, and to embrace each other and their Jewishness.
Leah, Rachel, and Shoshanna have a stormy history, and Pogrebin demonstrates that sisterhood can be a strong bond as well as a source of resentment, envy, and conflict. Pogrebin gives these three women well-defined personalities and we see how they change over time. Illuminating flashbacks shed light on how their childhoods marked them for life.
Where Pogrebin falters is in her writing style and plot development. She indulges in melodramatic and overwrought language when understatement and subtlety would have been more effective. At a little under four hundred pages, the book goes on and on; less would have been more. The author's feminist agenda takes center stage here and she pushes it so hard that it throws the narrative out of balance. A novel should develop naturally rather than serve as a forum to deliver political statements. Finally, the book is loaded with more angst than is needed in one novel. Some of the themes in "Three Daughters" are long-buried family secrets and grudges, marriages on the rocks, child abuse, mental illness, mid-life crises, and Jewish rituals.
Who will enjoy this book? Those who like to read about dysfunctional individuals who make an effort to bond after years of estrangement may find "Three Daughters" poignant and meaningful. However, since I found this novel to be more tedious than entertaining, I do not recommend it.
This book arrived at my house from the publisher...via a book review site. Somebody goofed. The only thing I have in common with this story line is that I'm the female offspring... Read more