| ||||||||||||||||||||||||
Product Details
|
Suggested Tags from Similar Products(What's this?)Be the first one to add a relevant tag (keyword that's strongly related to this product)
|
|
Share your thoughts with other customers:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Most helpful customer reviews
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Just like his ealier work - entertaining and well researched,
By
This review is from: Thunderstruck (Hardcover)
This book follows the exact same formula that Larson used in his popular novel Devil in the White City. Which is to say that it is one chapter about Marconi followed by one chapter about Crippen. While the back and forth style really worked to build up suspense in his earlier work, I found it kind of distracting in this novel. However that is not to say that this novel is dull. Far from it in fact.Larson provides the reader with an excellently researched novel concerning the history of wireless communication. For anyone interested in the life and times of Marconi, this fact alone should be compelling enough to purchase the book. Added to this is the a side yarn about one of England's "quiet killers" and the reader is provided with a book that is hard to put down. And just like Devil in the White City, I was disappointed that this novel had to end. The characters were so interesting, and the story so fascinating, that I could have read another 200+ pages easily.
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Another entertaining...,
By
This review is from: Thunderstruck (Paperback)
...and educational effort.It's easy to forget that Erik Larson isn't a novelist. But what he presents in this book, as in 'The Devil in The White City', is often tantamount to a novel. It's rich in texture, it's engaging in its complexities, it has characters to pique your interest...and just as with a good novel, you tend to wish it wasn't ending. Having said that, it also behooves me to say that 'Thunderstruck' isn't perfect. The balance between the two stories isn't quite right. And in comparison to the build-up, the ending doesn't provide...well, a fitting clap of thunder. (Sorry, I couldn't resist.) However, there's just so much stuff to wrap your head around that it's easy to forgive the book's shortcomings. And I have to admit, as a screenwriter, I kept thinking 'Could this be adapted to the silver screen?' Let's face it; if they can take a threadbare novel like 'The Prestige' and turn it into Nolan's masterpiece, than maybe it's possible with this gem from Larson, too. Time will tell.
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta) Amazon.com:
3.9 out of 5 stars (222 customer reviews) 322 of 334 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars
Mysterious and spellbinding,
By Robert Busko - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Thunderstruck (Hardcover)
I so enjoyed The Devil in the White City, a book I read without any awareness of its historical importance. I've waited with aniticpation Larson's next book, but this time I came to it with some expectation. Thunderstruck doesn't disappoint.If you're looking for a quick and unsubstantial book, Thunderstruct isn't for you. I can even anticipate that some reviewers will nail Larson for the incredible amount of detail he provides, especially in those chapters dealing with Marconi. However, this is Larson's manner and in the end you're glad he provided the indepth treatment. Thunderstruck, like The Devil in the While City, tells two stories that are inevitably intertwined. First, is Guglielmo Marconi's search for "wireless" telecommunication. Marconi wasn't a scientist. He simply had an idea. With his rudimentary understanding of electromagnetism he believed it possible to communicate over long distances without wires. He was a plodder in the best traditions of Edison. He was, of course successful. The second story deals with Dr. H. H. Crippen and the murder of his wife, Belle. Demanding, apparently unfaithful (though the Dr. appears to have gotten around a bit), and used to spending large sums of money they couldn't afford, Belle was a weight around Crippens neck. Along with his innocent lover and secretary, Ethel, he flees but is ultimately thwarted by Marconi's invention and a crackerjack Scotland Yard detective. The trans-Atlantic chase, reported via "wireless" communication kept the world's attention. Indeed, the only two people who didn't know they were being chased were the lovers. Written in Larson's uncompromising style using original sources, Thunderstruck is a wonderful vision into the early years of the twentieth century when technology promised a new world. The story is engaging, well written, organized. Larson is a master storyteller. Read the book. You'll love it. 116 of 122 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars
history even better than mystery,
By John C. Wiegard "Virginia Librarian" - Published on Amazon.com
This review is from: Thunderstruck (Hardcover)
This is two stories in one. The story of how Marconi struggled to popularize and refine radio technology by trial and error is fascinating, and the story of how mild mannered Harley Crippen became a famous criminal is nearly as interesting, and then the stories merge in a weird but memorable way. And every bit of it is true.I have to say that Larson puts it all together beautifully. He feeds you the perfect detail at the right time. It's not so much a true crime tale as it is a tale of human nature. It has a certain inevitability without ever boring you. I bet this one will spend a long time on the bestseller list, just like Devil in the White City (his previous book) did. 98 of 111 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars
50% fabulous, 50% boring,
By Melissa Niksic - Published on Amazon.com
Amazon Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Thunderstruck (Hardcover)
I enjoyed half of "Thunderstruck," but the other half of the book was a real dud.Erik Larson is one of several popular authors whose books always follow the same basic formula. In Larson's case, his books are divided into two separate plots that focus on different characters whose lives ultimately collide in an unexpected way. Also, half of Larson's book generally involve a very detailed process of some sort, while the other half revolves around a crime. When I read "The Devil in the White City," I enjoyed reading all the meticulous details about the planning and architecture of Chicago's World's Fair. However, I don't have a strong interest in science, so the entire portion of "Thunderstruck" devoted to Marconi's development of wireless communication was incredibly dull to me. I'm sure science buffs will find it much more enjoyable, but I thought that pages and pages devoted to things like the types of metals Marconi used to build antennas were incredibly dry and tedious. However, I really enjoyed the portion of "Thunderstruck" that revolved around the Crippen murder. Those chapters were much more intriguing than the Marconi parts, and I thought Larson did an excellent job of setting up the story. Also, I enjoyed the final chapters of the book where the Marconi/Crippen stories finally overlap. This book is based on actual events that I didn't know much about, and I'm eager to learn more about the Crippen case. (I won't be doing more research on Marconi, though...I'll leave that to the science students out there.) Overall, Larson is a pretty good storyteller. However, I personally only enjoyed about 50% of this book. I doubt most people will really get into the Marconi chapters unless they have a strong interest in the history and development of scientific processes. |
|
|